Joe's Brooklyn Pizza

Minimal flop and the undercarriage is crazy

The pizza was a bit undercooked for me and there was an excess of flour on the under side that left a chalky aftertaste. I ordered a large with pepperoni and 8 wings "special". The wings were undersized but cooked decent. Needed more sauce. No value here as my total was over $40. Could be decent with a few changes and improvements.

White & black garlic with the beer crust

Nice crisp on their original lacks a little bit of flavor Great crust Overall I rate this as 6.6 This is decent pizza

Damnnnn boiiiiii!!! I love this place. They had like 12 different specialty pizzas with all sorts of wild topping like Ghost Pepper Pulled Pork and a white pizza with black garlic, 2 different Sicilian style pizzas, and basically everything else you can think of. Crispy, Crunchy, slightly floured bottom, dough was great. The sauce on the Old Fashioned slice, blew my dick right off that’s how good it was. The cheese slice was great too. Perfect amount of cheese in my opinion. Not overly greasy or salty. It also wasn’t like rubber. It was smooth and tasty with a little bit of funk. Maybe som Redggiano mixed in there? Idk. Either way, great pizzeria with loads of options, priced decent, clean inside, prompt service.

Perfect amount of crunch pizza was really good.

This was great. The cheese was great the sauce was great and I had a wonderful crisp. Will definitely be getting it again.

Some good football pizza, surprising crunch! Undercarriage was good aswell. Great slice.

Slices in store are much better than ordering an entire pizza. Flavor is good, little bit of a greasefest, and flop city

As close to perfect as it's gonna get.

Lots of flop good sauce nice people fresh ingredients. That's a review

From a former citizen of Brooklyn I found this to be really good pizza. No flop. Very good crisp. Cheese was excellent. Loses .5 for the level of grease. My RIT son wanted to try authentic New York pizza and Joe’s did not disappoint.

Good pizza thin crust low grease with the roni.

The beer crust is amazing. This pie this time had no flop, excellent crisp, and great flavor. Great all around pie. Would travel for this one. On a side note the wings are really good and I suggest those as well.

Rating is for the cheese slice I had

Great crisp crust, sauce and cheese are season well. Overall solid pizza.

We drive 20 miles at least twice a month for our favorite slices. Joes Brooklyn does classic NY style pizza better than anyone in the local area.

Very good sauce. A little flop but not much. Crust is perfect. Overall just a great slice. This location destroys the Perinton location.

Great sauce, bit of flop, quality cheese, and perfect crust. A great NY style slice. Highly recommend.