Joe's Fleetwood Pizzeria

This was very good pizza, but not quite 8.x level. The slice had zero flop, really good crunch, and doughy crust. The sauce is very tasty too. My only issue is the cheese is just a tad too salty. Altogether, you'll be very happy you came here, possibly want an extra slice too (the size is too small, only about 9.5 inches whereas standard slice is 12 inch inches) since 2 won't be enough to feel full.

7.9

Undercarriage meant business. ZERO flop!

PHENOMENAL

Good slice perfect cheese sauce ratio with delicious crust

Phenomenal, everything a slice ought to be. My son loves it too!

Delicious, thin, crispy, flavorful, this pizza is one of my favorites

Cheese was actually an 8.3. Very good slice. But the Joes Special is a mess.

Crispy, no flop, no grease. Good taste! Dough seems to be of lower hydration. Solid pizza

Somewhere between a really good football pizza and less crispy than a bar pizza. Overall good.

Johnnys had a wildly long line so we stopped here. The people were super nice, but the pizza was just.. middle of the road.

Pizza is fairly middle of the road. Service was outstanding though!

Awesome people working here! Pizza was amazing!!

Owner has CHANGED since Dave’s review. They decided to keep the name the same with the old family’s photos on the wall, but brought their own pizza maker from NJ. Not the same. Never had a chance to taste the original, but the current state is just a run of the mill location. The owner has no idea who Portnoy is 😭

Good football pizza

Good crisp, very little flop, I can see why Dave gave this a 8.1. I’m feeling more of a 7.9. Imagine a good football pizza is a 7.8. This is a touch better. Just shy of the 8s in my opinion. The Sicilian is good as well but not as good as the traditional, so I’ll go 7.6 on that. Finally let’s be honest, nobody cares about white pies but me. Anyways, 7.7 on the white.

This rating is based on the plain slice. The Sicilian is better. Fluffy and light. The plain slice was good but dry. Crisp thin crust. Good cheese. But minimal sauce. I could see why people love it, and I wish I got a full pie. I’m sure it would have been better.