Great football pizza! A little doughy and the flop is real, but it's got good flavor. Def recommend if you're in the area and have a fever that only pizza can cure.
nyflpizza4/23/20, 4:56 p.m.
My first review of joes was based off slices. Buying a pie is the way to go! This pizza is legit!!! True NY style pizza. 9.4 is my highest score to date. The prez needs to come check this place out!
webev11/21/19, 5:06 a.m.
Good slice. Edges out I Love NY Pizza as the best pizza place on Old Winter Garden Rd.
iviola1210/31/19, 6:25 p.m.
Good presentation, nice atmosphere but super bland and greasy pizza.
pj.roy8/2/19, 7:03 p.m.
My second slice (pictured) was just as good as the first (plain cheese). Crust was crisp with just enough chew. Thin crisp bottom crust also. As close to authentic NY pizza I’ve had in the area. Very good
jbuzz3/26/19, 2:33 a.m.
Pizza looked decent in the box. However, it was bland, greasy and tasted more like that cardboard box it was in than anything else.
kris.boyce1/26/19, 1:13 a.m.
Good looking pizza at first glance, not lot of flop which raised expectations even further...but it’s way too salty. It’s like someone dipped it in the ocean before putting it in the box. Our second pie was a bacon/pepperoni split. Even saltier! The cheese AND the crust are salty. This pizza jacked up my blood pressure 50 points.