Had a slice of their white pizza as well as a classic cheese slice. Amazing crispy crust and sauce. Definitely coming back.
jbaker21711/13/23, 2:58 p.m.
Loved it, marinara sauce could have been better but enjoyed the crisp of the pizza breading. Highly recommend.
amadeus21310/9/23, 5:51 a.m.
Great pizza to walk around and pick up in Santa Monica. You hungry want something good to eat this pizza will hit the spot. Great crust and undercarriage.
lapatsfan9/19/23, 5:31 a.m.
Solid pie. Only knock is sauce was light on flavor. Perfect thickness. Good crunch. Left me wanting more.
jeremoah.back8/12/23, 5:24 a.m.
The dough tasted gross, but the crunch, undercarriage, sauce and cheese were all exceptional. A little disappointed, to be honest with this one.
15 views•1 like
cdgreen128/5/23, 9:45 p.m.
Finally, a real NY slice in California. Nice sweet sauce, good crisp, good cheese. Delicious.
williamjaeger7/22/23, 6:47 p.m.
Good pie, very NY authentic little shop. Got 2 slices and I would get it again for sure. Very thin pizza, had a little flop, but the cheese wasn’t falling off. Held together very good, every bite had a crunch and crisp. The crust was a little hard but that’s because I got slices and they threw it back in the oven. Overall a good pie, I’m sure getting a large pie would have been better like Dave did. Great sauce, you can taste that they care about the ingredients. Great spot right by the ocean.
mayorblueberryjerry6/25/23, 2:39 a.m.
I can finally say i had pizza in California. If you want a taste of New York Pizza come here.Sauce and the crisp are the best.
corey.mcbain5/21/23, 9:21 p.m.
I think old Portnoy was on the marijuana when he rated this place because this is not an 8+ pizza
10 views•1 like
redgonewild5/5/23, 7:28 p.m.
sauce is a bit sweet but delicious. tasty crust, excellent pizza, yum :)
mike.blasing3/15/23, 8:02 p.m.
Good pizza but thought the flavor was lacking in the cheese. Good crunch. Great undercarriage. Little flop.
ultimate.rating3/11/23, 8:47 p.m.
Busy at lunch with limited slices available. Steady stream of customers. Limited seating. The pizza is solid New York thin and strong, but the crust lacks character and leaves something to be desired. Solid crunch throughout but not worthy of an 8.
kurmas3/7/23, 11:10 p.m.
Perfect homemade sauce with a nice tomato flavor. Cheese was also perfect! Perfect seasoning and grease. Basically zero flop!
emma.sluiter1/30/23, 8:23 p.m.
Joe’s “New York City” slice was phenomenal. The sauce was top-notch… making the pizza go above an 8. This is the kind of pizza you can eat a lot of… thin, flavorful and fresh. 8.5/10. We also tried a slice of the “Sicilian Pizza” - 7.4/10. That is all.
jflor121/11/23, 4:39 a.m.
Very good za. Mine needed a little more crisp but Paul’s was cooked perfect