I’ve seen so many “bizarre” reviews. This is simply the best pizza in New Jersey. It doesn’t taste like “grease” (guy couldn’t even spell grease right). We ordered 2 pies and it seems like every pie that comes out of the kitchen looks completely identical to each other. Taste, presentation, quality. I’ve posted this pie on Barstool Pizza’s Facebook group and all of the participants on the group agreed this looks like one hell of a pizza. Stop by, give it a shot. Don’t listen to these idiots giving under an 8, they have no clue and those are rookie scores. I hope Dave is able to check this place out once everything is back up and running!
whells8/7/20, 11:08 p.m.
Great slice with a great taste and consistency. Not too greasy and solid crisp.
iiybi7/28/20, 6:44 p.m.
iiYbi.com Reviews. Solid Sicilian. Bottom of slice had a thin crispness while above that you could tell just how fresh that dough was and baked spot on. Light portion of tomato sauce how I like it and nice quality of cheese that baked into the slice very well. First time here will def come back
pizzadoc.jv1/29/20, 5:11 p.m.
Very greasy slice. Not sure how w everyone else scored thos place so high. Was looking forward to tasting it based on good pictures amd great reviews. 4.7 is just based on cheese and the sauce had a decent after taste. Greece was the only thing I can taste here.
27 views•1 like
john.dekenipp1/14/20, 6:09 p.m.
Too much cheese for my liking and it got a bit greasy, but it was pretty tasty. Anywhere in the mid-7’s is fair. Cash only spot. Old school.
52 views•6 likes
kevin.price1/5/20, 11:26 p.m.
Good find great place tasted great just a little to much grease and coulda used more sauce. But cheese tasted good and crust was really on point.
marc.san luis12/23/19, 12:21 a.m.
.....the flop was serious... But the sauce is nice and tangy. Good tasting pizza and I honestly hate most NJ pizza place but this was really solid spot!
sgtpet11/24/19, 8:52 p.m.
It’s a well cooked delicious slice of pizza. The only negative is it’s very greasy.
jon.denning9/8/19, 11:06 p.m.
Thin crust, crunchy, little twang, 3generations family owned for 73 years. Cash only.
mobsta8/7/19, 1:31 a.m.
Joes famous pizza 7.7 I can imagine if it’s a pie straight out the oven would def scored higher
130 views•1 like
4ortiz_pizza7/30/19, 11:36 p.m.
Great thin pizza, very flavorful and cheesy. Best pizza in the area by far.
jeffrey.davis7/13/19, 10:04 p.m.
Been going to Joes since the early 1960’s. Ordered my standard sausage and onion crispy but not burnt. Flop city😒
eatthatcrust7/13/19, 1:27 a.m.
Great pie. This is a pan pizza just for the record. So good though. Paper thin. Not a lot of sauce and basically no crust. It’s a light pizza but it’s spot on.
robbie.yachtzee6/28/19, 6:58 p.m.
Just tried Joe’s for the first time and wow, am I disappointed.This is the closest thing you will get to counterfeit pizza in the Tri State Area. Seeing reviews such as a 9.9/10 and an 8.6/10 for this place basically makes me sick to my stomach. #ShutThisPlaceDown
nick.iarrapino5/30/19, 11:16 p.m.
Great crisp, little to no flop, the sauce gives it a little tang, good thin crust. If there was a little less grease I would give an 8.4, but I have to go with a solid 8.1.
joemikehunt5/6/19, 7:04 p.m.
Joe's has a unique style of cooking pan pizza that leaves an awesome crunch. No plain slices ready today, but cant go wrong with Pep and Sausage.
debra.caplan2/24/19, 1:32 a.m.
Dave!! Please come to N.J. and review Joes Pizza. You will LOVE it. The family has been in business for 73 years. Joe (grandson of the original Joe) runs it now and you will love meeting him and talking to him.