Joe's Pizza

Really thin slice from toe to tip. Solid slice joint type slice. Barely any crumb even in the cornicione. Well baked on the bottom. This is a pic of their white. But I had that, their pepperoni, and a plain. It’s not fantastically great pizza. It’s in the range of what you generally find in the NYC area. But what stood out about it is the thinness and bake, though the picture of white slices was underbaked on top and bottom.

Iconic NY slice. Nice crisp + great sauce

Goof

Guest review!

Best pizza we've had in the city. By the slice. Friendly. Super fast. Good atmosphere. Not much seating inside but the flavors were fantastic!!!

Classic, very good. Crispy, slightly greasy, tastey.

Being that the pie I devoured from John's of Bleeker didn't fill me up that much even though I loved every bite of it, I figured I give this one a shot and eat it at the park. Although there was grease and flop at the first 2 bites, the insane char and fantastic sauce makes it worthy of playing second fiddle to John's. Come here if you just want a slice, if you want a pie walk to John's!

Perfect crust. Great sauce

Good pizza, cash only

Good, great, loved up to the hype, but not the very best in the city like they say

Nice crunch sauce is lacking

Alright old school slice in a arsty farsty neighborhood. Good fucking pizza though. I don't know all about the "this is the best pizza in the city" kinda shit. If you go to Brooklyn or Staten Island, almost every pizzeria has this kind of slice. Also hits the pocket. 22 dollars for four slices. This all being said really good standard New York Slice

101st review and I have eaten a lot of pizza in the last three days and this one still held up. The quintessential NY slice and it did not disappoint. This pizza made me feel like I was home. Just a perfect slice shop and I could not be happier.✅

This is the true NY slice . Perfect complement of cheese and s sauce and very thin. Reminded me of the pizza I had as a kid . Scottos in Cherry Hill. I would call this great Mall pizza because in jersey, the malls had great pizza .

Great sauce 10/10. Cheese okay, crust okay (but crunchy). Big slice which i like. Solid place.

Not sure there’s a better slice in the city

A NYC staple here, thought it was pretty damn good. Absolutely zero flop, loved the sweet sauce and the cheese was very fresh the crust had a solid undercarriage, but definitely could’ve used a little more flavor.