Joe's Pizza

Disappointing

Probably resting on the laurels a little bit. Good slice, but doesn’t stand out from the crowd anymore.

Maybe the best pizza in the city. Everything was great. Maybe outside crust could be a little better

It was a fine slice but not worth the hype

Just perfect, in the sense of normal pep pizza. Nothing special but it’s perfect. Reminder of old place I used to go to on 17th, near ensign!

Football pizza. Spider-man movie pizza place. Solid football pie but nothing to it. Doughy crust, mid undercarriage. Nothing that distinguishes the slice, but definitely upper end football pizza and would be a good hometown spot.

Would prefer a little more sauce, but the cheese and crust make up for it.

Good slice. Very busy so obviously a thing. I have had better.

Classic nyc slice

The crisp/crunch of the crust is what put this in the 8s for me. Plus it made me feel like Peter Parker. Shrug. Quinessential NY pizza slice

Super crunchy! ZERO flop! There is a reason this is still mob owned. Gotta product the recipe Mr. Crabs. Love it!

Crust is airy, love the sauce.

Did a slice of the plain and Margherita. This is a classic NY slice. The cheese and sauce are pretty generic but a good representation of what a good pizza is meant to be. Pretty well done and good crisp especially for slices. Margherita probably sat too long as the tomato flavor was very much not there. Stick to the traditional.

when i think of a slice of pizza this is the type of slice i think, just a classic slice. needs a little more crisp

Great pizza as expected. The cheese was a tiny bit overpowering but otherwise solid sauce, great crunch and chew

Light and crispy but still has a fluffy crust. Missing a little something from the sauce though

Turned back in & got two more slices after this. Full house in there, everything you want from a New York slice. Shut up good

Defines new York pie