jacob.503/11/20, 2:50 a.m.
Solid slice. Tangy sauce. Good cheese. Thin crust. Great crisp. Limited flop.
shawn.sumpter3/10/20, 8:51 p.m.
Its ok, im not going to rush back to get it again. The crust was good but the sauce was too sweet for me. It almost tasted like half tomato, half pineapple.
loganazza3/6/20, 11:40 p.m.
The perfect New York slice. Go for the Margherita over the regular cheese.
joe.dellamura3/6/20, 2:20 a.m.
Spot on best on outside of new Haven I’ve had... it’s an honest 1.2 less then Sally’s
ben.harris63/4/20, 4:41 p.m.
Posting this one a from last night. Had a slice after eating John’s of Bleeker so I wasn’t exactly hungry. That being said one of the best I’ve ever had! NY Pizza scene is bananas!!!
sean.bogue3/2/20, 7:50 p.m.
Thought this was absolutely stellar, exactly what you want in a slice. Love everything about it
jess.parker3/1/20, 11:52 p.m.
I love this Pizza! The Best so far. IMO better than Johns of Bleeker😳😳😳 The Best Sauce!! Perfect sweetness and bite. Amazing buttery crust . I want to give it a 9, but it was just a little to soupy.. The cheese would slide off. That being said it’s still amazing. Go to spot. Definitely best by the slice in the city.
yayitsck3/1/20, 5:43 p.m.
Looks like most other slices, but Joe’s is in a class of its own. Best quick slice pizza in NYC
ottoorange2/29/20, 5:29 p.m.
What a great slice! Loved the crunch and flavor of the sauce and cheese. Came out piping hot which always helps. NYC gem
soflafoodie2/27/20, 4:19 a.m.
Come on StoolPres, this place is not good. Crust has zero flavor
matt.soffer2/23/20, 4:42 a.m.
Those calling this an 8, i disagree with, very solid, quick, crispy, a strong football pizza, this, is a strong 7.9
jcaputo322/15/20, 10:36 p.m.
When someone asks what is the poster child for nyc pizza, the answer should be Joe’s on Carmine St.. This is the prototypical nyc slice that is at the top of the pizza pyramid. Sauce isn’t too tangy with tones of sweetness, cheese is great and crust is a perfect balance of crunchy and doughy. If you’re looking for that perfectly balanced nyc type reg slice go to Joe’s on Carmine St.
jerry.temple2/15/20, 8:22 p.m.
Quality slice. Great sauce cheese combo. Perfect char on the crust.