Joey Garlic's Newington

We went Detroit style and it was amazing. The out edges were crispy, light airy crust and the sauce was terrific!! We will be back to try their other pies!

Closest to New Haven style in the area

Another great CT pie. They took it back to make it more crispy for me. It's fantastic now. Great taste good crisp. ITS GOTTA BE WELL DONE.

Good pizza

Good crisp on the crust Some flop and a little greasy

Feels like “Greek” style and New Haven style had a baby but it didn’t come out with any stellar features of either.

Good crunch. No flop. Thin crust.

Went with the Vodka Pie a classic pizza with chicken and vodka sauce on it. Great flavor and crisp would recommend this to many.

Very good sauce with a below average crust... I paid extra for the fresh mozzarella and I don’t notice it at all... would be a solid 7 and change if the bread/mozz was better

Big slices

Vodka sauce: very bland. Not sure why there is chicken on it. Gets worse the more you have.

Small hamburger and hot cherry peppers

Up there with the best!

Good flavor. Crust was decent. Nice tang to the sauce. Solid pie.

Very good.

Great new haven style pizza in the Hartford area. Definitely one of the best. Very little CT flop, cooked perfect.

The go to pizza spot in Hartford County. Enjoy! Ryan L.