I’m convinced it would have been yummier if they weren’t slammed busy. A bit too greasy.
chasem4a6/10/20, 7:52 p.m.
I think Joey’s is my new favorite slice in Nashville. Very friendly staff and great atmosphere. I’m grateful to work right down the street and make weekly/bi weekly visits!
kenny.major4/3/20, 7:05 p.m.
This is hands down the best pizza in nashville, by far. Sauce has a night tang to it, no flop, fresh mozza put on after it comes out. Worth the trip during the middle of the day.
staffordoshee3/11/20, 7:30 p.m.
Good pizza but I was vastly underwhelmed compared to the reviews. It’s thicker crust and traditional New York style but still crispy. Didn’t seem like there was enough cheese on it for some reason. Sauce was excellent. The photo is of a gladiator slice, which I did not care for nearly as much as a regular slice. *** this review was updated from a 6.9. The little lady running the show in the kitchen... I have full faith that you could run the busiest kitchen in New York City without a problem. Seriously mad props to this lady she is a true professional that handles everything with equal levels of assertiveness, kindness, and professionalism. Looking forward to giving y’all another try.
john.o'connell2/27/20, 7:32 p.m.
Best pizza in Nashville great flavor and crisp crust. Best pie since I was last in NY
larry.giambalvo2/18/20, 7:07 p.m.
This is the best pizza you can get outside the NJ/NY area. Zero flop and perfect cheese and sauce.
jack.hudson2/3/20, 9:59 p.m.
Good crispy crust. No flop. Cheese was great. A little greasy. Little bit of tang. Overall, great pizza
wsinclair212/18/19, 1:17 a.m.
Good stuff. A little too crisp for my liking but best sauce I’ve had in Nashville.
zllozano12/12/19, 3:16 a.m.
Sauce had a good tang to it! Very little flop and the crust was on point. The fresh mozzarella was different however, it added great depth to the flavor of the pie. Crust was perfect. The atmosphere was just as good. Overall Great pizza and worth the drive to get it.
74 views•0 likes
notdave12/6/19, 7:14 p.m.
Joey’s house is the real NY Italian feel. Love the attitude and hard work you see there. Plain cheese pizza. The crust isn’t thin but it’s got a perfect crisp and crunch. The sauce has a pleasant tang that you can’t figure out. The only downside was I felt it was lacking enough cheese. Which doesn’t make sense because you’ll see them load up fresh pies with cheese.
mike.shoults11/11/19, 8:44 p.m.
Best slice I’ve had in Nashville. Great crisp, fresh mozzarella, and good sauce! You can really tell they care about their food. “Steph” took care of me, I will definitely be back for another slice, and a cannoli!!
adam.higgins10/31/19, 8:25 p.m.
This One stands alone. Absolutely zero flop, crunchy crust, fantastic flavor! All this off a slice pie. I bet it would be a guaranteed 9 were I able to get a pie. (I walked in right before close at 3 PM.)