Joey's NY Pizza

Undercooked slop. First review was good. Have been back a few times now and every time since is garbage. Very poor quality control. Employees can’t even use a pizza peel. Improperly trained. Screen pizza not worth the price.

this pizza was love at first sight, a real Brooklyn style pizza.

Pretty bomb pizza , sauce and cheese were well balanced crust was good wish it was a little more charred but still bomb

Best pizza I’ve had in Colorado Springs. Tastes pretty similar to east coast pizza

Solid NY style pizza. Lil flop. Good char

Almost hit that 8.1. Closest NY style pizza I’ve had in Colorado. Sauce could use a little more flavor. Great crispy crust. Football pizza all day.

There’s something about this pizza that is pretty unappetizing. Excellent crust, but other than that it leaves something to be desired.

Consistently decent pie for Springs. Never going to ‘wow’ you but probably won’t disappoint either. They deliver if that’s worth something to you.

Good sauce on the pepperoni and marg. Small flop. Bianca (white) was personsal fave. Will return. Cool restaurant

Power

Slightly undercooked. Has a good flavor and good cheese. The sauce isn't overwhelming but noticable. Quite a bit of flop but it is a large slice. Overall probably the best pizza in the area.

Very good slice, best I’ve had in Colorado Springs

Average slice. Biggest flop I’ve ever physically witnessed. Probably due to the large amount of sauce, which was offsetting the sauce-cheese ratio. So too much sauce, and a pretty acidic slice, but overall not terrible. Solid 5.8, average slice.

2nd time in a row the pizza not cooked proper doughy and just not good !!

Alright here we go. So I did get my pepperoni slice out of the window, since everyone seems to be talking about the difference between the fresh pies and the window slices. My slice was well done,almost burnt but that is how I like my slice. Absolutely 0 flop on this pizza, no New York flop going on. The pepperoni on the slice was actually excellent the sauce and cheese were pretty average. I enjoyed the crust because it was crisp how i like it. For the oil there was just enough not too greasy at all. Overall a very solid slice I think it can hold its own as a decent ny style slice. 7.6 from me.

The pizza came out looking promising.... as soon as I lifted my slice it fell apart.. I came here a few times before and got window slices and to be honest I was fairly pleased. This time I ordered the fresh pie and I’m thoroughly disappointed. There’s so much oil on the pizza the taste is over powering. My pizza absolutely fell apart, and the sauce was..well...to say the least mediocre. I can barely say this a football pizza. For this to be called a “New York” pizza is a lie. 4.7...that was all she wrote.

I went to Joeys a couple weeks ago and I was pretty pleased. I bought a few slices out of the window the first time. The slices were crispy, not too much flop, and the sauce was excellent. This time around I decided to buy a whole pie fresh out of the oven. I was not very pleased. There was so much flop my pizza was practically falling apart. I could fill an Olympic size swimming pool with how much oil there was. Those both ruined the pizza for me. This is a drunk pizza at best. I’m giving it a 5.3. That’s a review!

Major flobbage. Zero crunch but still Decent football pizza. Needs a few more minutes in the oven. Sauce is ok, not my favorite.

A nice crust with a little crisp to it. Cheese was not fully cooked and the sauce was more tangy and chunky than I’d like it to be.