Joey’s Pizza Depew

Had a bit of a sweeter sauce. Good flavor overall. Not much crisp but overall a good pie. Bit of a thicker pie.

If you love Buffalo Pizza, you’ll love Joey’s. Great toppings, light crust, and people friendly.

Super soft bottom, and really nice ingredients spicy pepperoni sweet sauce. I really like this pizza

The sauce is amazing just a touch of sweetness. The pizza is thick but airy cheese is great. If you love super crispy pizza this isn't it . Just a great tasting pizza if I lived here this would be a go to.

+ for sweet sauce, crisp crust, atmosphere - for sauce distribution, consistency of slices

Solid Buffalo pizza and always consistent. Hidden gem of the area. Friendly and very clean atmosphere.

Cheese and pepp sheet was cooked great, sauce is fantastic, dough was light and fluffy. Everyone loved it. Best pizzeria in Depew IMO. Will order again next time I'm in the area.

I’m a fan of Joey’s. I like the sweeter sauce and they use good pepperoni. The dough is a little thick but it’s Buffalo and everyone’s is. They are also consistent which is rare nowadays.

Solid slice with plenty of pepperoni and tons of grease. Sauce isn’t to sweet but still very good

Good slice , pepperoni on point... solid 7.9

Another first review today... It was thrown back in the deck for a reheat... Great crisp from the slice and the crust was light and airy. The cheese is incredibly fresh and there’s a thick layer of it. If you like cheese, this place doesn’t disappoint. The sauce was plentiful and a little on the sweet side but blended well with the entire slice. Overall, this is really good pizza.