John And John's A Pizza Shop

Great sauce and perfect crust.

Above average slice. Cheese and dough were legit. But kinda wish it was cooked a little longer, undercarriage was a bit too soft.

Good crisp and flavor. Cheese is the way to go. Didn’t care too much for the pepperoni.

Some of these reviews are all over the place. For what this is, a more traditional NY Style pie, it’s one of the most solid ones in Orlando. The sauce is definitely interesting but it’s solid. The undercarriage and crust are perfection for a NY pie. A better quality cheese puts it in the 8s. Very solid overall and will be back if in the area.

This was a decent pizza but was not my cup of tea, not a fan of the cheese , the bread was a little chewy but love the choice in the small pepperoni slices as they tend to come out a lot more crispy

Crust is average. Could use more cheese. Sauce had some ting. Pepperoni helped to increase the score.

Cheese Slice

This is a great local pizza shop with qualities of a classic New York pie but with their own spin. Nice thin, solid crust and a savory sauce really makes this pie stand out. Two great pizza spots right next door to each other but with completely different styles to enjoy.

Best NY style pizza in Orlando. Perfect crisp, zero flop, great sauce, quality cheese, good people, old school vibes in a new spot. It’s my favorite and my kids also prefer it. Not even near my house but I make the trip every Friday.

I think a 7.5 is perfect for the rating definitely a place I’d come to a lot if I lived in the area but I wouldnt drive far for it. Very crispy just no taste to the crust and place has a cool old school vibe. If you are in the area definitely worth a try

The upside down with roasted garlic. Fantastic. No flop good crisp.

Great crust sauce was good…we need to send el presidents here!

Decent undercarriage, eh tasting sauce (like my sauce a little sweeter and more pronounced), mid cheese, good crust. Overall okay pizza give it a 6.2

Great crust! No flop, crunchy. Had the cheese and the Margherita. The Margherita slice was so good I took home a whole pie. Best pizza I have had so far in Orlando area.

If your team was playing the afc/nfc championship game and you were having friends over that were also fans of that same team this is pizza in Orlando you would order to enhance the vibes.

Very heavy but tasty. Solid undercarriage. Had both a steak & a vodka sauce pizza. Def recommend.