Johnny Napkins

…good tasting pie. Good sauce and super cheesy. Floppy and under carriage could have been more well done … but def an enjoyable pie.

As I said in the review, the plain slice probably wasn’t from a recently made pie. If it was I likely could have bumped it up into the mid 7’s. Good crust on the slices I sampled. That vodka slice with ricotta was absolutely phenomenal. I’ve since went back just to get that slice again. Gave that an 8.2 easy.

I order from here all the time and for some reason today I was not the biggest fan. Maybe it’s cause we had it delivered but the crust was almost hard to chew. I do love this place. When u walk in the pizza is great and the other stuff on the menu is delicious.

Greatest pizza in NJ!

Pretty damn good lil grandmas pie with vodka sauce instead of pesto would have been better but it was cold had to hear it up.

I’m all about the interesting pizza so today we have a Sicilian pie with pepperoni and everything bagel seasoning. And yes, it tastes just as good as it sounds

Slight flop but not a ton. Sauce is really good but not enough imo....cheese overwhelmed it but not because there was too much...it just wasn’t enough sauce. Not much crunch to the bottom but the crust was crispy with a little bit of chew and just enough salt. Quality ingredients...pepperoni cups and chars like good pepperoni should. Cheese slice gets a 7.1. Solid place.

The second guy doesn’t support the troops

The Brooklyn, upside down sicilian

Decent pizza

The square slice is definitely a winner at this place.