One Bite App | Pizza Review App by Barstool Sports
Download
Home
Top Restaurants
Johnny Tomatoes Pizza

Johnny Tomatoes Pizza

4260 South Tamiami Trail, Venice, Florida
Pizza Review
0 likes
mark.zildjian on One Bite Pizza App

mark.zildjian

12/8/25 5:09 PM

Cooked perfectly, didn’t have to ask for well done like I usually do. Zero flop, dough had good crisp and flavor. Love the cup and char pepperoni
Pizza Review
cubanpizzamonster5/9/26, 12:29 a.m.
Pizza review

4.0

Terrible, first the cheese tasted like absolutely nothing. Sauce was minimal and whatever sauce was on there had no real flavor. The pizza was cold and the dough was like pulling on cardboard. The pepperoni was ok, same issue with sauce and just as chewy as the cheese. The garlic knots are a whole other issue. They have garlic shavings on them, so much so that you will taste the garlic for the next 6 days. This pizza in Venice Fl is advertised on their front store entrance s voted best pizza in Venice. If that’s the case, I am extremely concerned about what’s waiting for me here, since I’m moving to the area in 2 weeks. I’m giving it a 4 just not to be heartless.
0 likes
Pizza Review
pizzabrat11/24/25, 12:07 a.m.
Pizza review

8.1

I guess this is a new pizza spot in the area. I can’t believe there aren’t any reviews yet. We’re from Chicago, and have been on the pizza hunt in Florida for a looonnnng time to mostly disappointments. Far and beyond - this is legit, real deal pizza. I hope they get signal boosted and have the success they deserve. Great crust - crisp and thin with some chew. Great flavor (we get it well done). 8.1 best we’ve had in Florida
1 like
(941) 493-1515
4260 South Tamiami Trail
Venice, Florida 34293
Something not look right?
Suggest an Edit
Barstool Bets - Barstool Gambling
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Instagram
  • YouTube

© 2026 Barstool Sports. All rights reserved.

Terms of UsePrivacy PolicyContent PolicyContact UsApp Support