Not a great slice but it grew on me. We ain’t in New York no more! But it’s not bad. Papa Joe’s was kinda like a grandma. If it was warmer it’d be better but it had a nice taste on there 6.9 for granny.
Order now on Slice
Order Johnnys New York Style Pizzeria & Restaurant
Hungry? Order right now on Slice
ohmypizza4/29/22, 5:29 p.m.
This is for the cheese: tangy sauce, crust is pretty good. The Papa Joes slice however is PHENOMENAL. That one gets a 8.8
treylondon3/13/21, 12:12 a.m.
I rated two pizzas from Johnny’s. So I put the better one as my score, so that the worse one wouldn’t pull their general One Bite score down.
18 views•2 likes
mark.henry12/17/21, 4:48 p.m.
Awesome slice, and about the best you'll find in Virginia. Great flavor, thin and crispy. Love this place.
ravi.narayanan6/21/20, 6:58 p.m.
Finally got a chance to visit the Mecca if NY pizza. The best thing about the pizza is the quality of the cheese and the sauce. My regular slice I did not like the dough. My square is very good. Just not hot and tons of oil and major flop.
kevin.sechrist1/2/20, 7:29 p.m.
Sauce was tangy and had a little Spice. No flop. It was a little greasy but overall a solid slice. 6.3, that’s a review.
asianpizzadude10/24/18, 11:39 p.m.
Very bleh slice. If this slice punched me in the face, I’d forget about it in about an hour. Boring cheese, lame texture, sauce was tasty, and the first bite or so had good texture, crust had a good crisp but was underwhelming. Better than Sbarro or mall pizza.
210 views•1 like