Been goin to Johnny's for about 30 years.(FBest around since they were on Gramatan Ave. and you had to bring your own plates!) NEVER take this pizza home without bei g able to reheat, uncut of course, NEVER. All the review pics showing a box, would be higher if they had sat and enjoyed it. right there.0
terrence.manning5/14/22, 4:03 a.m.
Prez nailed the review. Super crispy. Awesome sauce. Not too cheesy but you dont mind. If an 8 is a drive worthy for your area. this is outta state drive pizza
jeff.milarsky3/18/22, 1:45 p.m.
Pizza is fairly tasteless. Props given for consistency and execution. I simply think the dough is oily yet crunchy and the whole package is average.
mister.slice3/7/22, 6:04 a.m.
If you like old school, traditional, thin & crispy pizza, this is the place to be! The sauce on their pies is absolutely sensational…it’s got tang & bang up the yin-yang! I’d travel over 3 hours just to smell this pizza! This might be the best pie outside of Brooklyn.
cole.hastings2/25/22, 9:38 p.m.
Fantastic pizza. Not quite has good as davey said but still great. Lady serving us was a bit rude but not letting that influence the score. Strong 8.3.
michael.caterino2/16/22, 6:16 p.m.
One handsome looking pie . Very thin . Flavorful sauce. Killed the whole pie in 5 minutes between two people . 8.7
anthony.pizza32/3/22, 9:44 p.m.
Something makes me want to give it a 9+ but idk..sorry this isn’t helpful but amazing slice
abbizza12/11/21, 11:12 p.m.
Triple Threat: Sauce: Marcella Hazan’s recipe? Crust: Light, zero flop, big crunch Cheese: Just enough tucked under the sauce Add a few ice cold Peroni’s…perfection.
mike.whelan11/22/21, 1:11 a.m.
Amazing sauce, think crust, the right amount of cheese. A must have!