About Johnny's Pizzeria
404 Yelp Reviews
alex.handler2/5/23, 8:09 p.m.
Pizza was gas (it wasn’t actually gas). No flop great crunch, workers were very nice. Gotta go back!
charlie.goodstadt2/5/23, 8:08 p.m.
Hands down best pizza I’ve ever had. Zero flop. Great vibes. Worth the trip. Highly recommend.
jay.marine1/20/23, 8:35 p.m.
I know this may not look like a 9.1 ~ but it absolutely is. Wow. This was my 3rd attempt getting pizza from this spot. The first was when they closed because of a fire… 2 weeks ago I got there when they first opened and didn’t have time to wait an hour for a seat or a pie so had to leave. Don’t go when they first open, wait til about 2pm. Straight from an employees mouth to your ears. That’s what I did and finally ate lol. So thin, little crisp, sauce is amazing, cheese is amazing, undercarriage ~ you guessed it: amazing. Perfect pizza all around. This is a must visit. I’d put it in my top 5. It’s that good….
bigdaddytom871/20/23, 1:09 a.m.
For those who thought Dave was crazy for his 9.1, it's not unfounded! The sweet sauce is addictive, the crust is nicely charred and saltine cracker thin and I was able to slam down this "small' pie by myself and I don't have the itis! This is elite pizza!
nathaniel.rodriguez11/12/22, 4:24 p.m.
One of the best places in New York. The pizza had almost zero flop and amazing crisp. The sauce was so flavorful. The cheese was melted to perfection. One of the best slice’s I’ve ever tried.
finkey.cold.medina11/1/22, 5:08 p.m.
Thin with lotsa crunch! No flop, flavorful sauce, very light cheese. Very solid pie!
daveturner10/7/22, 2:35 a.m.
Old school pizzeria, hidden next to a laundry mart and across the street from auto repair shop, cash only, where the waitress calls you “hunny”. Crust was amazing, thin crust firm cooked to perfection with tons of flavor - crust could stand on its own. Next a thin layer of low moisture mozzarella cheese followed by a plentiful sweet ‘old school’ sauce on the top. Napkin please! Pizzeria Beddia & John's of Bleecker St are my only 9,s It’s been a while since I’ve scored so high and very rare I’ll give a score in the 9’s, but this place deserves the 9’s, hits on all marks. Exceptional top shelf - worth traveling to even in massive NY state thruway traffic!
john.chase19/23/22, 8:08 p.m.
Outrageously good pizza. You gotta go here if you’re anywhere near the area. As crispy as it gets, sauce on top which is phenomenal, and just an overall amazing slice of pizza. Doesn’t get much better than this.
tbocchino948/17/22, 5:47 p.m.
My kind of pie. Sauce was just a bit sweet, couldn’t decide if I liked it even more or was indifferent to it. Sauce to cheese was great crisp was awesome. Great slice. When you walk in and it’s pies only and also cash only, chances are it’s a good pizza
randy.bankos8/15/22, 7:10 p.m.
Yep it’s the real deal… crispy, crunchy, great flavor. They didn’t have the Johnny’s pizza box but I didn’t mark off for that
drewdutches8/2/22, 3:28 a.m.
the perfect crisp. 12/10 on crispness. If you love crispy this is it. The sauce on top of the cheese takes away from saltiness of cheese leaving it a bit plain tasting. 9/10!