david.dowling10/21/20, 12:23 a.m.
Very crispy and nice and thin . Loved the burnt bubbles on top . Only thing is it needs a little more flavor perhaps oregano or basil ?
onemorebite10/16/20, 1:07 a.m.
Great texture. Nice and crunchy but bland. I don’t usually put peppers and garlic on my pizza but this one needed something. This is a one and done for me. Dave has this one wrong.
pizzavore10/10/20, 7:51 p.m.
Small cheese pizza and a bottle of water, 2pm on a Saturday, $18.00 Pros: Amazing crisp to undercarriage and crust even more so. Taste is fantastic, every bite carries the flavor of delicious crispy char. Thin layer of sauce on top keeps it from being dry and the oil is just the right amount. I enjoyed this more and more with every slice til it was gone then searched for crumbs. Cons: You have to eat it quick, I got carry out and it lost a lot of heat in the short walk back to my car due to its super thin crust. A little pricy but I'd do it again every day if I could. Verdict: Lives up to the hype. Johnny deserves his face on the Mount Rushmore of Pizza, bless that man's pizza making soul
anthony.celano9/28/20, 5:15 a.m.
A very simple pie. Cheese,sauce a little Pecorino and olive oil. Super thin and crispy. The magic is in the sauce.
ecao9/25/20, 12:01 a.m.
Had the large regular pie and a grandma pie: both were sublime, the crust is second to none, the bottom of the round pie was very uniformly crisp, although there was no flop, but that didn’t take away from it at all; sauce is very good, sweet, but flavorful; grandma pie was almost just as good, basil/spinach (not sure which??) glaze was very good; only negatives were that it was very oily (the thinness definitely accentuated the oiliness) and that the cheese wasn’t anything special (but the volume of cheese was perfect)
donaldtrumpusagodblessus9/18/20, 9:24 p.m.
Westchester has seen a surge in pizza quality since the destruction of nyc by commie Blaise and emperor cuomo. Lucky this pizza is above standard and approaches next tier category. With the US open in neighboring Scarsdale at the winged foot, I can see an oasis here
rms179/16/20, 11:27 p.m.
Thin crisp. Well done. Sauce is good. Cheese doesn’t have any influence. Pretty oily.
neftali.reyes9/13/20, 1:37 a.m.
Pizza was good needed more cheese this is not what I expected Dave is out of his mind rating this so high not a bad pizza but never near a 9.1 and the staff is crazy rude especially the mama at that cashier she got a mouth on her and also please don’t buy the meat balls you’ll be in for a surprise !!!
dominic.annese9/6/20, 3:28 a.m.
Second time here. Last time i had to eat while driving and it was cold. Incredible pie. Personally my favorite pizza
bud.bulgogi8/9/20, 9:46 p.m.
Great pie. Crust is what makes this pizza, thin and crispy with some very welcomed char.
dmormino108/4/20, 7:24 p.m.
Super Thin, Super Crunchy. Phenomenal Pie. Could eat the entire thing in one sitting, that’s how light it is.
t-rex.pizza7/25/20, 11:24 p.m.
There is really no more accolades I can add. This is hands down the best!
joey.bloey7/24/20, 11:41 p.m.
Very very good. This is what I expect from a New York pizza. Crisp, char, crust was great. The sauce could have used a little more...something. Otherwise a fantastic pizza.!
jamie.levinson17/21/20, 5:36 p.m.
Prez was right on the money on this review. The pie is extremely unique when it comes to the sauce, cheese and especially the texture of the crust. Highly recommend going out of your way for this gem!
jerbraska7/15/20, 6:26 p.m.
Out of all the high scores Prez has given out this was the most disappointing. Star Tavern is better. The plain slice at Joe & Pat’s in SI is better. This...totally overrated. Tasted no cheese whatsoever; might as well had no cheese at all (but yeah, I confirmed there was cheese). I was basically just eating plain tomato sauce on bread
joe.zukeee7/8/20, 10:21 p.m.
Been goin to Johnny's for about 30 years.(FBest around since they were on Gramatan Ave. and you had to bring your own plates!) NEVER take this pizza home without bei g able to reheat, uncut of course, NEVER. All the review pics showing a box, would be higher if they had sat and enjoyed it. right there.0