Second to only Di Fara’s Brooklyn & just ahead of John’s of Bleecker! Cooked to perfection, the crunch, the sauce! Amazing.
mark.d35/30/20, 7:09 p.m.
Fantastic thin and crispy pizza that I would get weekly if it was my local pizza joint. The pepperoni slice was a 9.0 and regular was an 8.7 so my overall score is an 8.9. Very solid pizza and one of the best I’ve ever been had.
dominic.annese5/29/20, 9:38 p.m.
Had to get it to go and drive around while eating which hurt the score. Cooled off, in a box its a Solid 8.9. Would have been a 9.1 sitting down inside. The woman who owns it is amazing as well.
greg.keely4/28/20, 6:55 p.m.
I love the amount of sauce on this pie. Nice char on the crust. Great taste. Well worth the trip to Mt Vernon.
mike.casach3/17/20, 8:48 p.m.
Sauce was excellent but due to the drive home the dough wasn’t as crispy as it would be if eaten right away.
josh_rose3/12/20, 11:22 p.m.
Best crisp I’ve had on a pizza so far, consistent throughout. Flavors were amazing too. Number one in my book right now.
alfredo.vasquez3/10/20, 6:30 p.m.
I got there at 9:45. I ordered at 9:30. I live less than 5 min drive from the joint. I’ve can die and to heaven knowing I’ve tried one of the top 5 pizzas in my lifetime. I rank with Difara and Johns of Bleeker category. The cheese is just right with some sauce on top of the cheese. Best eaten right away piping hot burning the roof of your mouth. Best Pizzeria in all of westchester county
elena.french3/7/20, 6:10 p.m.
I wasn't thrilled when I first saw it but looks can be deceiving! Absolutely delicious. Super thin. Super crisp. Perfect amount of sauce and cheese and flavor on point. I'm a fan. Husband gives it an 8.6.
justin.mondello2/28/20, 7:46 p.m.
Listen...I'm all about being fair. And I am very open minded when it comes to pizza since I eat any pizza you throw at me...this place has a lot of hype. I got there at 12:15. 15 minutes before they opened, and there was a line outside. The first guy in line drove 3 hrs to get there and he told me that he thought that Johnny's was the best pizza in the entire country..bold statement. I'm gonna say this. Very different style of pizza then I'm used. It's a mind fuck because it was so different and so thin. When you got to the sauce and cheese you had an explosion in your mouth, but there was not much sauce or cheese on this pizza. I'm guessing it because the pizza is so thin they can't afford the risk of the extra weight on top. But, when you hit these ingredients they were very good. I would not travel 3 hrs for this pizza, but since it is a local spot, I am definitely thirsty for more. I feel like if it had pepperoni or some other topping it would have been a 9 for me. But overall great, and different pizza. The End.
amory.blaine2/22/20, 12:09 a.m.
Granny square with basil - solid 8.5 (best of 3 pies we had) Score determined along slide suasage, pepper, garlic pie and 7.7 and eggplant pie 7.9
vinny.ruggiero2/21/20, 2:31 a.m.
Pizza was pretty good but I expected a little more with all of the hype. Good crust, mellow on the sauce and cheese. Don’t need to go out of my way to come back but good if I’m in the area.
kenneth.correa2/15/20, 1:54 a.m.
8.7 and Portnoy gave it a 9.1. Crispy, thin, not cheesy...I loved it, but based on el Presidente I xpected more.
ed.cruz22/14/20, 11:20 a.m.
Johnny's Pizzeria by far has some of the best pizza I've ever had in my life. I grew up in Brooklyn with places life DiFara's but my mother-in-law grew up and lived upstairs from Johnny's original location in Mt.Vernon. I had the pizza for the first time last night and it was amazing.