Next day! Was great yesterday too. Awesome pizza.
dmormino108/4/20, 7:24 p.m.
Super Thin, Super Crunchy. Phenomenal Pie. Could eat the entire thing in one sitting, that’s how light it is.
t-rex.pizza7/25/20, 11:24 p.m.
There is really no more accolades I can add. This is hands down the best!
joey.bloey7/24/20, 11:41 p.m.
Very very good. This is what I expect from a New York pizza. Crisp, char, crust was great. The sauce could have used a little more...something. Otherwise a fantastic pizza.!
jamie.levinson17/21/20, 5:36 p.m.
Prez was right on the money on this review. The pie is extremely unique when it comes to the sauce, cheese and especially the texture of the crust. Highly recommend going out of your way for this gem!
jerbraska7/15/20, 6:26 p.m.
Out of all the high scores Prez has given out this was the most disappointing. Star Tavern is better. The plain slice at Joe & Pat’s in SI is better. This...totally overrated. Tasted no cheese whatsoever; might as well had no cheese at all (but yeah, I confirmed there was cheese). I was basically just eating plain tomato sauce on bread
joe.zukeee7/8/20, 10:21 p.m.
Been goin to Johnny's for about 30 years.(FBest around since they were on Gramatan Ave. and you had to bring your own plates!) NEVER take this pizza home without bei g able to reheat, uncut of course, NEVER. All the review pics showing a box, would be higher if they had sat and enjoyed it. right there.0
rob123717/2/20, 5:15 p.m.
Crisp, thin and light in the cheese. The right tasting sauce, what's not to love!
james.madsen16/30/20, 9:33 p.m.
Best pizza I've had on my work trip to NYC. Thin n' Crispy, hot n' fresh out of the oven. That being said, the staff was not great the lady that took our order was rude, impatient, and pushy. I honestly would have rated it lower, but didn't want the shittiness of the staff to reflect on this amazing pizza.
pizza_joe6/26/20, 12:02 a.m.
Good but not great. Needed more cheese and didn’t have the kick I was looking for.... still very sold pizza. Thin
lnorinsky6/20/20, 6:27 p.m.
Very crispy and tasty thin crusted pizza made with a lot of tangy sauce. The pizza had a nice char but it needed just a little more cheese to be amazing. The slices were consistent throughout and were very good. An all-around very good pizza and the best in Westchester.
mark.d35/30/20, 7:09 p.m.
Fantastic thin and crispy pizza that I would get weekly if it was my local pizza joint. The pepperoni slice was a 9.0 and regular was an 8.7 so my overall score is an 8.9. Very solid pizza and one of the best I’ve ever been had.
dominic.annese5/29/20, 9:38 p.m.
Had to get it to go and drive around while eating which hurt the score. Cooled off, in a box its a Solid 8.9. Would have been a 9.1 sitting down inside. The woman who owns it is amazing as well.