Johnny's Real New York Pizza

Delicious greasy floppy mess. Cheese slide off after a few bites.

Horribly expensive, all flop, garbage pizza. The fact that Brooklyn’s Finest in Oak Creek shut their doors and these guys are still around is laughable.

I’d like to amend my previous review by apologizing to Dominos & Pizza Slut for comparing them to these slices…after careful consideration I realized that my score was too high and should have been in the 4’s, this is more like 7-11 pizza

More flop than Lebron. Terrible.

Extremely doughy and undercooked. Not much flavor. Far from “real” New York pizza.

Crust is good, thin and a crunch. A little light on sauce for me, the cheese about right. Whole pie would have been higher score.

Johnny’s is good New York style pizza. The large size is actually a large and the crust is thin and really good. A solid pizza for sure!

No flop and a crisp crust. Sauce could use a little more tang, but overall a solid bite.

Decent sized slice, a little New York flop and a bit greasy. Crust had a good crisp but the rest of the pizza was too doughy for my liking. Perfect amount of cheese but the sauce was eh. A little bland not much flavor. Probably won’t come back unless I’m in the area.

Tastes like thin digiornos. Ordered both pepperoni and cheese. Tasted dry, not good reheated

This is half the slice that I got. Honestly it’s up there with the best slice I’ve had in the OC so far. Haven’t ordered a whole pizza but the slice was really good. Great crunch, light flop. Solid slice

Solid slice. Ask for it Crisp, proper.

Very good pizza. Not too much flop and cheese and sauce both very yummy. The crust looked crispy but wasn’t super crisp. Nice thin slice and my son enjoyed the ranch!

As the Presidente might say himself at best it's football pizza. It's not bad it's not great it's ok if your in a hurry and just want to grab a quick slice. There aren't a ton of slice only options in Irvine and this I'll get you through the day. Bit greasy, little crunchier than I'd prefer but service is good they have a we beers on tap and some cooking wine by the glass.