John's Of Arthur Ave

Huge slice! Needs 2 plates! Some flop but crispy fresh crust. Very tasty! 100th review!

Much better than Caputo's

Based solely on the gold standard cheese slice, I thought it was a really good slice. Could use a little more sauce and cheese but it was quality ingredients and it was a massive slice. Bonus buffalo chicken slice: 4.9 - I thought it was one of the worst buffalo chicken slices I’ve had. Cheese had no flavor, there was no sauce under the cheese of any kind and the chicken was just meh.

Serious flop. Lacked flavor. Needed to be cooked more.

Really big slice .. needs a little more sauce and crispiness for the crust.. the king gives it a 7.5