John's of Arthur Ave Restaurant & Pizzeria

When asking why my pie was cold the manager flashed me his gun.

Used to love their pizza before covid. But now the thin crust, extra chrispy tasted like a cardboard pizza. @chef_craig on YouTube.

Nice crisp crust. Good flavor. A little greasy. Solid basic NY style slice. Would eat it anytime.

The slice was great overall. Not too thin, not too thick, however it flopped in the middle when I held it. The undercarriage was more solid towards the crust, which made the crust so good. There could have been more sauce in my opinion to match how much cheese there was, but that’s a personal preference. Cheese mixture was also great. Would absolutely go back again or order before a game. Side note: Also ordered their graffiti pizza which was incredible. The vodka sauce and the pizza sauce dollops made the pizza!

This score is for the Graffiti pizza. Very good. The regular pie is nothing special.

One of the best pies I’ve had in a long time.

Best pizza in Milford by far. Quality , greatly recommended

A must when in Milford PA the pizza is the best around. Here is the graffiti pizza you haven't lived until you had this pizza

Good slice in PA

Very good slice, nice crisp, no flop and sauce has a nice flavor. Definitely recommend

So far the best slice since I moved to pa.gotta switch the ratings around to composite back home pizza standards . This is northeast pa 9.1. Grandma slice is amazing

Tried the Family Pie, could definitely eat this often.

Solid crispy slice, sauce is nice and tangy, overall I’d recommend to everyone.