John's of Bleecker Street

This is the epitome of NY pizza for me. Crisp thin slices. Perfect sauce, perfect crust. I could inhale a whole large. Very good pizza and loved up to hype

Great dough/crust, good sauce to cheese ratio. The coal fire taste really comes through which is great, but the sauce could have more flavor. Overall worth going for...$48 for two plain pies *before* tip though, seemed high.

Really expensive, good flavor not great. Somewhat underwhelming, chewy crust even when cooked well done.

The cheese and sauce didn’t have much flavor but this was the best crust on a pizza that i’ve ever had

Very accurately reviewed by Dave. Amazing pizza. Close to rival lucalis. 2nd favorite pizza spot of all time

One of my favorites of all time!

I don’t understand how pizza can be this good

Great pizza, very light, doesn’t make you feel sick after eating 4 slices. Sauce can have a little more umph to it but overall amazing pizza.

a VERY good slice of pizza. that being said, i do think that there could be better pizzas out there. sauce was impeccable, cheese was fresh, crust was krispy. however, i wish it would be a little bit saltier or have some more umph

Our review of Johns of Bleecker Street

Good crust. All around good pie

wayyyy too much flop and cheese, but still a good pizza

Loved every bit of this pie and the old school decor. Honestly the only reason I won’t give this is a 9 is that the tang gets to me after a couple slices but the best pizza I have ever had in Manhattan by a country mile.

Got damn that is good

The pizza is amazing. I drove all the way home to my house in n.j and ate it cold and it’s still a 9.3

Great sauce. Right amount of cheese. Perfect thin crust pizza.

Prez, you need to have your head checked. This is not a 9.3. Floppy and greasy!

I don’t know if it’s because I have been living in Michigan for the past 5 years but this is the best pizza I have ever had in my life

Came up from Philly. Angelos is amazing but I think they both tie at first for me. The crust is so chewy and the sauce is so tangy and delish.

Coal fire cheese. Very good slice! Sauce is sweet. Ingredients taste fresh. Heavier than I expected.