John's of Bleecker Street

Rookie score but pizza was bussin

There is a good reason why people line up down the street for this place. Best pizza in NYC. Crust was amazing. Sauce was even better...great flavor and texture. The cheese was perfect. Looking forward to eating a leftover slice tomorrow.

Awesome pizza a bit greasy but amazing

Straight up, best pizza I've ever had. NY or otherwise. Not a slice shop, gotta buy a whole pie. But you won't regret it. Just so ridiculously good.

Good pizza to much of a hype. I’ll go with a 7.5

Very good though not as good as hype. Excellent crust. Good flavor all around. Sauce was a little bland and overly canned tomato flavor. Would eat again though not going out of my way.

By far one of the best pizzas I have ever had. It gets better with each bite, cooked perfectly good cheese good crisp; my only complain if I had one would be too much sauce, it had too much of that marinara taste but other than that, amazing pizza. Worth the trip from wherever you are to go.

Amazing.. no other words

Great pizza! Pres was definitely right! This was the best pizza I’ve had and eating outside made the experience great! Loved it and would highly recommend!!

Lives up to the hype. No flop, crispy crust and undercarriage, light on sauce, perfect amount of cheese.

Solid sauce, not enough cheese and sauce though, solid slice

This was bangin. My favorite of NYC so far. Perfect crust, sauce, and cheese

Top shelf wouldn't cross the 9 threshold. Sweetness of the sauce was outstanding no flop but prefer more crunch. Next time no pepperoni plain side better!

It’s really good. Not sure 9.3 good but very good for circle pizza

OVER - RATED

Perfect soss to cheese ratio, ANAZING FRESH SOSS, but the crust did not do it for me. I appreciate that I didn’t have to shit myself after.

as of 4/22/21 this is the best pizza I have ever had. the sauce is so damn fresh. and the cheese to sauce ratio is magical. don’t bother getting anything other than a straight up cheese pizza. do like daddy dave does. also I appreciate the grunge on the aesthetic. anyways, stop wasting your time and come here.

Lived up to the hype, sick crust and sauce, amazing cheese

I work in the South Bronx and live in NJ but that doesn’t stop me from grabbing a pie or 2 after work and hitting the Lincoln tunnel. I usually eat one pie driving home. The coal fire taste is unique. The cheese and sauce are amazing. Absolute best I’ve had so far. Plain pie is the way to go.