John's of Bleecker Street

This is not 9.3 level crisp. That’s a lot of flop. Sauce was average.

Great pizza, not overly greasy or floppy. Great crisp

Fantastic. Sliced meatballs with pepperoni. The garlic in the meatballs combined with the unbelievable sauce created the winning taste on this pizza. Some of the best I’ve ever had

Always make a stop here when in NY. Amazing pie with the best oven taste imaginable

Incredible

Did not live up to the hype.

One bite everybody knows the rules, amazing pizza great pepperoni, sauce had lots of tomato flavor and the crust was perfect . It’s a “tell all our friends pie” that’s a review.

Order well done!!!

Lives up to its name fucking great pizza

Absolutely phenomenal pizza. Light, tasty, and just about perfect

Really good but not earth shattering.

Thought this pizza was a little overrated. 9.3 from Dave too high. But not my preferred style pizza / doesn’t feel NY style to ME. Definitely a good pizza tho. Crust a little thin to not enough cheese but a solid pizza nonetheless. Good crust/not floppy and the sauce was great too. Line is pretty crazy tho

Crisp bottom but the crust had a little crew to it.....Perfect sauce to cheese ratio

One bite everyone knows the rules. So el Pres is undeniably the for most pizza expert in the world. 3 days in the city 3 pizza stops. The sauce was by far the best a John’s. There was substantial flop. Crust was really good and so was the undercarriage. I can’t give it over a 9 . It was so light and flavorful it was the best so far and anybody would be a fucking retard not to stop here while I’m the city. I may have offended several groups by this review. If so fuck off and grow some balls.

Great crust, excellent sauce. Nice solid flop and undercarriage. Thanks Pres.

Crust was terrific.

We got it with extra cheese and it was phenomenal. Worth the trip down from Boston.

Best pizza I’ve ever had. Better than Italy

Living up to the hype, super light sauce, great crust, amazing taste!