Order now on Slice
Order John's of Bleecker Street
Hungry? Order right now on Slice
paul.carozza12/5/21, 11:19 p.m.
NOT MY PHOTO. I forgot to take a photo when I ate the pizza. I must say tho I was very disappointed in this pizza. After hearing about how good it was I was extremely disappointed. The sauce was so acidic that I had heartburn for hours after eating it. The crust was very good and was a redeeming quality but the sauce was just so damn acidic. Some slices were very floppy and some were not, so it doesn’t seem like it was evenly prepared. I think this place has become very hyped since Dave’s review. Although I respect Dave and know everyone has the right to their opinions this is not a very good pizza to me. Easily overrated.
alex.brann12/5/21, 4:11 p.m.
Just a tad floppy in the middle but overall amazing. Crispy crust, good sauce, nice undercarriage
erin.barnes12/3/21, 6:53 p.m.
Really really disappointed in the pizza at this place. The hype is not anything like Dave Portnoy says it is. I mean, I’m from NC and this pizza place Tipsy Tomato in the middle of no where has way better pizza then this place. You’re going to be disappointed. Trust me.
danny.miller1111/30/21, 2:51 a.m.
Tastes like grocery store cheese. Overall a doughy slice but with a nice burned crust. With Pepperoni I give it an 8.1 thanks to the added saltiness
andy.blackburn11/29/21, 7:22 p.m.
Pilgrimage all the way from Gibraltar to sample John's of Bleeker. Lived up to the hype!
jose.regal11/28/21, 3:22 a.m.
It’s all about the sauce and the coal fired crust and texture. Best sauce in NYC.
beau.rathjen11/27/21, 11:48 p.m.
We traveled from Oklahoma City to NYC and had to stop at John’s. Easily the best pizza we’ve ever had. Can’t imagine having a better gold medal slice! 💙💙
tpierce0911/21/21, 3:51 p.m.
Great pie, sauce was awesome, dough had a good crunch and fun atmosphere. Buy a shirt while you’re at it.
tonyswkim11/16/21, 3:07 p.m.
Had the original cheese pie. Certainly, one of the best pizza places I have been in NYC.
steveos11/16/21, 2:09 a.m.
Went to NYC and found John's Original. One bite .. was like butter!! The taste one the fresh tomatoes and the real cheese..mixed with that light crispy crust. I wish there was a spot like this in Hamilton Ontario Canada
justgivemegoodpizza11/15/21, 10:55 p.m.
Lava in the middle, but lives up to the hype. Sauce and crust were on point!
tyler.gronbach11/15/21, 12:04 a.m.
This is Gas, you've tried the rest, now come have the best. Grab some meatballs too.