John's of Bleecker Street

Next level, nothing like it. A must when in NYC

Glad I tried it, but isn’t worth the hype. Mediocre at best.

So damn good. Visited from Texas and this was the one place I needed to eat. Didn’t disappoint. The crust was light crispy and had a great taste. It was charred in the right places.

Cracker like crust not necessarily my speed. Under carriage very solid. Cheese and sauce as good as it gets on pizza.

You going with a group, well they better be standing there or you'll get skipped. Other than that we really enjoyed the pizza. We did do the pepperoni and cheese. The pepperoni wasn't bad but kinda like hormel. The pizza was excellent, my son said it was the best he's ever had. The sauce did have a great flavor. Not sure why some people said it didn't but I would highly recommend. Looked like a bowling alley pizza but didn't taste like it. Would absolutely go back again.

Crust and sauce were first rate.

Best pizza I ever had!! No flop, crunch in every bite-perfect!

Absolutely incredible. If you like the true New York style thin crust with a touch of that coal char on the crust, this is the place. Best pizza I’ve ever had.

The fucking sauceeeeee. That’s what brings it all together. The crust is excellent, perfectly cooked. Slight char with a nice chew. Thin but not too thin. Very light weight, light enough for me to have ate the whole thing in less than 10 mins and not feel heavy afterwards. By far the best pizza I’ve had to so far. My favorite in NYC.

Wow, this was amazing. Seriously the best pizza I’ve had in my life. I’m not sure how it gets much better than this. Cooked perfect, sauce and cheese to die for. Great pizza.

Visited from Atlanta, and noticed this was a highly rated pizza on the app. It lives up to its hype. This is a great pizza. Crispy crust, great sauce and perfect flavor of cheese.

Very slight flop and grease but not too bad. The sauce is unreal and crust cooked to perfection. Super light, could eat a whole OG pie. Top tier stuff, recommend the OG and Picante

High score! Very good crust and sauce, old school vibe inside with lots of celebrity pictures.

Wish it had more crisp but other than that an amazing pie!!!

Pizza is pretty good. Maybe in my top 10... maybe. Ambiance is nothing special. Glad we went but it's not a 9.3 in our opinion.

Tied with best pizza so have ever had. We got one cheese and one with cheese and extra sauce

Best classic cheese pizza I’ve ever had.

Holy moly

Great pizza. Sweet sauce. Light enough that you could eat more slices than you think with a great crisp

It’s pretty… pretty…. pretty fucking good.