John's of Bleecker Street

Great pizza! Tough to beat.

Can’t believe they make pizza this good

A nice New Haven style, a little undercooked and the sauce lacked something.

It's floppy. The fundamentals are there. Just a little too soft and floppy. Might be a tad bit overrated. But still strong

Incredible dough, sauce and pepperonis

Awesome char. Great sauce

So good! Crust, sauce and cheese lived up to the billing.

As good as it gets. This place has to be on your pizza list when you come to New York.

Best pizza I’ve ever had

Absolute heaven on a pizza pie. Practically perfect

Great service pizza even better. Absolutely must go if you’re in the area!

An amazing pizza, if you are in Manhattan please come here it’s arguably the best pizza i’ve had.

Crust is unreal. Issue was it was cold so the review can’t be fully authentic, but for the bite it was absolute quality

fucking amazing new york pizza

Absolutely amazing pizza and an awesome environment

If not the best, top 2 I’ve ever had. Incredible pizza, can’t go wrong. Had half cheese half sausage. Sausage was traditional ny/nj sausage

Absolute sex. So good.

This pizza is so exquisite one of the best pizza I’ve ever had. The cheese was so gooey and elegant I would go here if I were you

Coal-fired pizza is definitely unique in all the best ways. Probably the best pizza I have ever had so far, definitely will be my first stop if I find myself in New York again. Restaurant crew was great as well!

Probably best pizza I’ve ever had. Staff was also super welcoming, super fast, and they felt like family.