John's of Bleecker Street

Hard to score over Angelos, so it’s a tie

Dave is finally right on his scores. Sweet sauce and good coal fire.

Top notch NYC pizza!

As good as advertised! I absolutely loved it, but had to add salt because the mozzarella they use really lacked flavor. With a little salt it was the best pizza I’ve ever had.

First stop in New York Didn’t disappoint 20 wait in line-moved quickly well organised Very good

Wow just Wow this is a must stop for pizza in NY.

Sweet sauce, clean taste. Good chew on the crust.

Wait staff was excellent. Pizza was good but over hyped.

Holy grail of pizza. Tangy sauce, crispy crispy crispy crust. This is an A list slice.

As a lifelong NYer and a lifelong pizza lover, I just had to take the near hour train ride down here. Not even my local Johnny's can light a candle to these guys. Half plain, half pepperoni with a pitcher of root beer. Don't get the glass, get the pitcher, you'll get your money's worth. Calling this perfection of a pizza "delicious" is a straight up insult! Any true pizza lover NEEDS to visit here at least once in their lifetime!

Fantastic pizza, burned my mouth off

Over hyped pizza just because Nicolas ate here!!

Tangy sauce. Thin, crispy crust. Light cheese. Worth a visit.