Zero flop. Sauce is robust enough. Coal supplying heat adds a slight flavor to the crust that is enjoyable. Similar to grilling with propane vs. charcoal. Not too much grease. Not heavy feeling afterwards. Definitely recommend.
Order now on Slice
Order John's of Bleecker Street
Hungry? Order right now on Slice
sean.newsome18/7/22, 3:07 a.m.
Another overrated pizza on this app. This pizza is actually nothing special. Don’t believe the hype.
will.ketelsen8/6/22, 8:51 p.m.
This pizza is amazing. The crust is perfectly crispy and chewy, the cheese and sauce are delicious, and there was zero flop. The staff is also very nice. Overall, if you are in the city you definitely have to go here.
vonnegut8/4/22, 7:11 p.m.
The holy grail of pizza. Out of this world excellent, haven’t had any better and doubt I ever will. It will change your life. I’d give it a 10 but I’m no rookie and holding out a bit from that in hopes there might be something better out there. My new purpose in life is to find that place if it exists, but If it does it would most certainly by served by God himself.
loudermilk8/3/22, 1:48 p.m.
Quality fresh sauce. Great cheese. Today, unfortunately the crust was average. Average taste, average crisp, which brings down the score. Very, very good pizza. Good location. Old school inside. Very nice staff.
jerseypies8/2/22, 10:07 p.m.
Holy shit this was just as good as i expected! Probably the best after taste I’ve had in recent memory. Put together perfectly with a crunch that was light and crispy. I could eat this sauce in a bowl by itself if it was acceptable. One of the best I’ve ever had!
thomas.moore137/30/22, 6:18 p.m.
Excellent as expected the crust was one of the best in nyc overall incredible
alex.bush27/28/22, 7:06 p.m.
Went 2 nights running. Night one was great. Night two the crust was a little over done but still a great pizza. Lovely job. If only I lived in nyc.
clkgg7/28/22, 4:37 a.m.
Great classic coal fired pizza. Perfect ingredients. Great crisp. Just got wait in line and try it. It’s what all other places will be rated off of. Great atmosphere. Sit by the pizza oven.