I was actually a bit underwhelmed given all the hype about the place. Solid slice, but not in the 9’s for me. I likened it to Santillos in NJ which I actually find a notch above this pie.
mcnulty7/14/20, 11:20 p.m.
Best in Manhattan. Tangy sauce. Crust is both chewy and crunchy. Travel for this pizza.
jim.kontoveros7/11/20, 10:40 p.m.
Great pizza, great service. Gotta try it or you’re missing out!
chadt7/11/20, 5:54 p.m.
Little flop, good strong cheese flavor, sauce is ok, definitely more greasy than I expected, the slice is thin but not crunchy. Crust is good but it’s no 9.3
elyseparker7/11/20, 5:43 p.m.
A lot of hype for little flavor. Good pizza, great quality cheese but the sauce lacks in flavor. Very plain tasting. Thin dough with tons of flop, very greasy. Overall good pizza but no where near great.
jonathan.stanley7/10/20, 6:11 p.m.
Pie was soggy and sauce just dripped off like water. Cheese had no flavor. Could hardly taste any flavors. Gets a 2 for decent crust. Sadly lowest score I'd give so far on my lizza excursion. Only took 4 minutes for pie. Maybe it was just thrown together too quickly. No way this could be the same pie everyone else has been rating.
nick.roussas7/8/20, 9:01 p.m.
Went to John’s of Bleeker Street on Monday night, sat outside in the street for outdoor dining, the pizza was amazing, the crust was crispy the sauce had an awesome taste it wasn’t sweet. Can’t wait to go back! Also had a sausage and peppers pizza that was delicious!
ryanloewy7/7/20, 8:14 p.m.
Franky this is as close to perfection as you’re gonna get. Absolutely fucking amazing. Amazing crisp, beautiful marinara, cheese was perfect. Crying tears of Joy. That’s a motherfucking review Frank!!!!
chris.krug6/25/20, 10:01 a.m.
Cheese was definitely good but it tasted more like bread with some tomato sauce and cheese rather than an actual slice of pizza. The pepperoni and basil pizza was better but still not like other places in the city
maxfairbank6/24/20, 1:41 a.m.
Wish I could’ve had this thing hot...Dad just brought it home after a 5 hour trip to NYC
jim.murphy76/23/20, 8:37 p.m.
Dave was right, best pizza!! Took a road trip with 2 buddies from Boston!! Mike the server was great and we are bringing 4 pies home
alex.hartelust6/17/20, 9:28 p.m.
John’s OG Bleeker Street, half pepperoni. Cooked perfect, one of the favorites
51 views•2 likes
emjaysea6/16/20, 11:42 p.m.
The crust is perfection—charred without tasting burnt. The sauce, not overly acidic or sweet—a wonderful balance. Although half the pizza had ricotta, it was not oily or soggy in the slightest. The hand feel of the pizza is amazing, zero flop with the slight residue of “pizza dust”. Worth it, order for pick up during the pandemic! Edit: I had to re-post this review with a more appropriate score. The more I thought about it, the more a rating of 9.0 didn’t do this pizza justice.
jason.cataldi6/12/20, 10:48 p.m.
Very good over all . Amazing crisp. Just very thick tomato-y sauce
miked7106/8/20, 10:03 p.m.
I shouldn’t have waited to eat it getting back into Jersey. Crust was incredible, sauce was excellent, I can definitely see this being in the 9’s fresh.