John's of Bleecker Street

As good as it gets

Final pizza at NY

Looks incredible, dough cooked perfectly with a nice undercarriage, the middle of the road nyc style thickness. It’s very good, the sauce is light and mild yet tasty but the cheese lacks the flavor to put this at the top.

It’s all here. Sauce, crust and cheese. Not much to say except perfection.

Amazing!

Great pizza but definitely a bit overrated, maybe I caught them on a bad day or something. Also they should keep up with the appearance outside, trash everywhere…not a good look if you dine alfresco.

Half cheese, half meat lovers. Best in NYC out of the 10 I’ve tried

Top 10 NY sryle pizza. Outstanding balance of everything for NY pizza. Great tasting sauce & ingredients without being overpowering in any way. Cooked to perfection even though they were slammed. Crust has just the right amount of crispness & thickness. Highly recommend.

What a pizza! Light, delicious, crunchy, tasty. All you need from a great pizza. I was amazed by the crust… but sauce was great too! A must in NYC. I will go there anytime I’ll be in the city

Lives up to the hype. Great crust and sauce.

Great crunchy crust, firm no flop, sauce a tad sweet and great, hard to beat so simple and good, a must have…

Beat pie ever. Could be more floppy though.

Sorry, I just don’t get it. Maybe John’s is just too close to pizza in Italy, but this just tasted like not-very-good Italian pizza. Sauce is too sweet. Mozz has not much taste. Bland. My wife loved it, though, gave it in the 9s.

Amazing, service great, pizza fantastic

Good pizza, solid pizza. A standard. Maybe needs a portnoy revisit, a little greasy and very standard cheese. Tangy sauce and good cook on it

Great undercarriage. Had to come since it’s my first time in NYC.

Good pizza but expected a little more considering the hype.

Good charcoal oven taste. Lot of flavor kicking in the first bite, but I don’t love when there isn’t sauce under the cheese. Soft chew to the texture, maybe 2mins in the box hurt the crisp. Was trying to find my new top spot but I’m gonna keep looking.

The pizza here does not need a bunch of toppings. They only get in the way! Amazing.

Amazing! One of the best in NYC!!

Hands down One of the best Pizza’s I’ve ever had.

Alright Frankie… the famed John’s of Bleecker Street! Great sauce and it feels light for a NY pie. Awesome wood-fired crust too! Definitely worth a trip just for it.