John's Pizzeria of Times Square

Oddly not as good as John’s of Bleexker even know they have the same recipe. Could have used another minute in the oven

Love the sauce

Paper thin with a unique saltine flavory dough which complements the sauce and cheese well. Unique twist in the cheese with a parm reggiano taste. Could have been a little more well done. Bit floppy. Could use more evenly distributed sauce too. Excellent za though

Good but really floppy

Good crisp, great flavor.

Tangy sauce, little flop. Check your pockets.

This is one of the best pizzas I’ve ever had in my life. Went here because of Dave’s review and everyone thought it was amazing

I’ll be honest, I was quite surprised at how hard this hit. It’s not one thing that carries, it’s a group effort here. The cheese and the sauce collide perfectly. Nice thinner crust that has a good hold. Definitely some flop but not some loosey goosey slice. Overall amazing slice

Easily best pie I’ve had, even after waiting 30 mins for a seat! Very fruity sauce and tasty cheese, with that NY thin crust crisp we love. Only 9 review I’ve given.

Sauce makes the pizza! Nice crunch just a little too much grease for my liking

Really REALLY good. Light and crispy not too heavy on the stomach…sweet flavorful sauce.

Great ratio of cheese/sauce staring out of the oven. Not a terrible floppy flop, and nice dough. Gave it an extra 0.5 because it was surprisingly good cold pizza the next morning. A bit overpriced also.

Taylor Swift * Ariana Grande

A rich tasting tomato sauce with a great ratio of sauce and cheese. A little bit floppy but a great tasting pizza nonetheless.

A little New York flop, but the sauce was amazing as well as the sauce to cheese ratio. Very very good!

Perfection, great service even for a busy Friday night