cwall02712/1/21, 8:00 p.m.
These pies lived up to the hype. Amazing taste, not greasy, and great service. Crust had a PERFECT crunch! Highly recommend!
theot9611/26/21, 5:39 a.m.
It was very good, the sauce was very light and I loved that. I would not recommend any toppings, I think this would of been a higher score if I went with just cheese.
barron.jackson9/7/21, 11:57 p.m.
Pizza Review #2 (RESTAURANT THE NOTORIOUS P.I.E NOT FEATURED ON ONE BITE)
4 views•0 likes
rosey123453/24/21, 4:06 p.m.
LOVE LOVE LOVE this pizza!!!!!!! It’s one of my favorites in NY! It’s in an old church so it’s also historical! The sauce to cheese ratio is *chefs kisses*
rob.effler7/5/20, 2:03 p.m.
I’ve been to John’s half a dozen times and they are always on point. Being able to watch them make in in the brick oven in the dine in experience is always pretty neat. Quality pizza a bit pricey. Best quality of the sauce is the tang it comes with. The pizza is built with the cheese placed first and then the sauce. Beautiful presentation of each pizza, with a decent drip factor. Service: C+ Presentation: B+ Cheese: B Sauce: A- Crust: B+ Texture: B+
scott.evans43/14/20, 3:40 p.m.
Score per Elizabeth. It’s a fair score. Wonderful sauce but really soupy. Major flop. Slight crisp. Needs to tighten up.