Really delicious sauce and cheese. A bit too greasy, crust was unremarkable. All in all, really enjoyed it.
jbrancs9/29/22, 2:31 a.m.
It turns out that this lives up to the hype, very tasty thin bar style pizza, cracks the 8s
pizza-dan9/11/22, 9:16 p.m.
Right up there with other Johns. If I was local to NYC I’d be in troubles. Everything was great Pizza was incredible
pizzacigarpuffs8/28/22, 1:33 p.m.
Decent NY pie good taste Cheese overpowered the whole flavour if you like a good pie for cheesy this is the one
aaronpinto8/28/22, 4:04 a.m.
Pizza Backlog 13 | 8/27/2022 | I’ve said on this very app that it would be tough for another NYC pizza place to beat John’s of Bleecker Street. And even though I remain correct, John’s of Times Square came damn close. Theirs is also a thin pie with crispy crust and sauce on the always-welcome sweet/tangy side. The only things keeping me from giving it a score in the 9s: (1) a little too much cheese for my optimal experience and (2) the non-crust parts were a little chewy. Both of these are mere quibbles on a fantastic pie.
funky.pizza.lover8/27/22, 4:09 a.m.
A ton of cheese, so best consume it while it is hot lest you encounter some undesirable coagulation; sauce was okay but it could have elevated this score if it possessed some tang/zing; undercarriage/crust was crispy on the edge, yet the tip was a sloppy dangler; less than ideal on the form as the slices broke apart upon extract (drippy); dough was tres fresh with a buttery hue; an enigma; overall pretty good; side note - great service and nice atmosphere.
cpfc8/20/22, 5:03 p.m.
Classic NYC slice. Great flop, solid sauce, and good crisp. Great atmosphere as the ceiling calls for God’s pizza. Down side too many tourists
andrew.francis28/12/22, 4:20 p.m.
Fantastic Pizza. The building also has stained glass all over which indicates to me that this is where Jesus eats pizza.
geats8/8/22, 7:22 p.m.
Good New York pie here. Nice cheese to sauce ratio, great crunch. Floppy but crunchy. Well done. Till next time NYC
eliza.funk8/4/22, 8:34 p.m.
this is a tricky one… the potential was totally there but unfortunately we picked it up & walked for a while so when we eventually tried the pie, it wasn’t warm🥲 but the undercarriage & sauce was impressive👌🏼this is a pie worth trying!
barrydrewzreview8/4/22, 12:35 a.m.
Not sure if we hit it on a bad night or not. Under cooked in my opinion. Crust could have been crispier and too much cheese and not enough sauce.
casey.hornbeek7/26/22, 4:37 p.m.
Very solid New York style pizza. Amazing cheese good crust and overall great pizza. Tastes very good. A little greasy only negative.