John's of Times Square

great crust, above average sauce, too much basil

Great pizza. Super fresh and not too heavy. It didn’t seem as greasy as when Dave did his review.

I don’t get the hype around this. It tastes pretty average and doesn’t have a lot of crisp

Perfect crust. The cheese was great too. A little bit of flop.

Perfect crust

Classic Pie. Good quality but nothing too fancy. Shout out the homeless man doing the 5 knuckle shuffle across the street from the place

Good flop, good grease, good crunch. Late night after flying in, this pizza hit the spot

It was good not great, not overly crispy but good taste, kinda disappointed but I’ll try bleekers next

This place was a total let down. Pizza was very soggy, very greasy, and a lot of flop. I will say this place is VERY touristy.

Classic was amazing… super thin and crisp. Margherita was good but prob in the sevens.

Phenomenal. Cheese had great taste. Great crunch to the crust. Not too greasy, not too much flop, cheese didn’t fall off the pizza. An authentic italian pie.

Pizza is killer.

Ignore Dave, this is a 7.9 and that’s the official review.

Best traditional cheese pizza I’ve eaten. Bought a jar of marinara to go.

Best Pizza I’ve had in NYC.

Easily as good as Deninnos in the village. Worth the visit!