John's of Times Square

Good slice

🔥

It was worth the hype. Great sauce.

Really good pizza, the only thing I’d do different next time is order it well done. The crust was good but I prefer a less floppy pizza.

🔥

We had John’s on Bleecker Street. This was so much better. I think you got the scores flip-flopped. This deserves a 9.2 and John’s on Bleecker probably an 8.0.

There’s something not as good as the Bleeker Street location, it seemed a bit more greasy or floppy or something…but still really damn good!

Margherita - too much basil

I thought it would have more flavor. The crust is perfect, and the ingredients taste very fresh.

A love song came on during my first bite

Gluten free traditional. Perfect sauce cheese balance. Crispy. No gluten goo or crunch.

Sauce is similar to Bleecker St, but nowhere close on the crisp and the whole thing falls short

Perfectly crispy, flop was perfection, sauce and cheese spectacular, only thing losing points for was a bit too much grass. After being here a year ago and being let down, as Harry said “…you go and do something like this…and totally redeem yourself” Ordered the margarita pizza btw

I had the privilege of watching them prepare this pizza. They put the cheese on first and the tomato sauce on second. The cheese is actually delicious, could have a little more bite to it. Overall exceptionally delicious.

great crust, above average sauce, too much basil

Great pizza. Super fresh and not too heavy. It didn’t seem as greasy as when Dave did his review.