dan.brodahl12/9/20, 1:27 p.m.
Excellent pizza and calzone. Great location. The ceiling in this place is unreal - it’s an old church.
andy.luca2/7/20, 2:20 a.m.
Really delicious pizza, overall. The sauce is really good and the cheese and crust is pretty good, too. It’s thin and easy to eat, which I always love. Definitely check it out if you’re in the area.
randy.warnock2/2/20, 5:14 p.m.
We ordered a traditional pie and it came out cold. Very disappointed. The slice has good flavor but coming out cold ruined our expectations.
shhmeehan2/1/20, 2:53 a.m.
Good crust, great sauce flavor. Toppings were lacking in taste that kept from an 8+
nicolás.eliçabe2/1/20, 2:10 a.m.
Una slice de GorDough en La Plata, te lleva a NYC en un segundo! 💪🏼🤘🏾🍕
jay.marine1/31/20, 11:19 p.m.
I’m going 7.7 on this one. Would have been higher if more well done. Overall good score, good pizza, cool spot. Place used to be a church. Service was slow as shit lol. Bathroom upstairs almost made me throw up. Is what it is. But it’s about the pizza and that was a solid slice.
bradfromthefort1/22/20, 2:42 a.m.
Alright Frankie, it’s time for a review. We’re here at John’s if Times Square tonight. We have a traditional NY cheese tonight and it just came out of the oven. One bite, everyone knows the rules. Cheese to sauce ration is perfect. Little flop with a crunchy first bit. Good char on the bottom with a crunchy crust. Phenomenal slice that I couldn’t put down. Tonight they cooked this pizza perfectly and I have to say this is a great slice. I’m going with a 9.1 rating! And that’s a review.
justin.turner1/17/20, 11:49 p.m.
Crust is light, sweet, and fluffy. Sauce is on the sweet side as well. Very little New York Flop. Very good pizza!
bbold1/13/20, 3:37 a.m.
crust was too thin near center causing it to droop and have cheese and grease run off. was very greasy. I liked the texture of crust around the edge. it was a decent pizza, but not one that I would have to have next time I was in town. the location however is amazing. probably saved them from a lower score
matt.southmayd1/6/20, 11:12 p.m.
This is one of my favorite pizzas that I have ever had. It was seriously good pizza and can’t wait to go back