John's Pizzeria

I expected more. The sauce and cheese had a nice unique taste but there was too much cheese, even for a cheese lover. Crust was crispy, but the rest was too chewy. My scores are becoming more evolved I’ve noticed from my previous reviews. I would have rated this higher earlier on. It’s good if you’re in the area and the side of meatballs (with sauce) are some of the best I’ve ever had.

Good crust, tangy sauce, heavy on the cheese…if the cheese was a little lighter Im going 8.2-8.4

Looks and flavor make this a 9+…but I was surprised how doughy it was for coal fired? It was crisp, but didn’t have that nice crunch to it. All in all super solid and won’t disappoint.

Not the same as NYC but a good pie...fresh, soft crust..

Great ingredients. Very crispy personal pie. Huge oven. Nice pie.

Nice taste, just enough crisp.

I'm surprised I liked it I thought it was going to be a low-scoring pizza tbh but it's very good

Nice crisp, great sauce to cheese ratio. A bit on the thick side for me, but all around very good. 7.6 is on the money, that’s a review!

Very good New York Style Pizza. This pizza was very nostalgic, can't believe I have missed this place. I am from Jersey City... The crust has a good flavor, the sauce is perfectly done not acidic. The Cheese is good with a nice chew to it. Will be back!

Top 10!!! better then the one in the city hands down!! Bucket list pie and some of the best meatballs I've ever had!!

Nice crispy pizza with a sweet sauce!

Amazing

Solid

Great pie overall. Only constructive criticism I can leave is the sauce:cheese ratio was a little off. a little light on the sauce.

This was a solid 7.5. Sauce and cheese were good. Personal size is always tough to grade.

Got the Margherita. Its really good pizza, but had to deduct a few because the kitchen took a long time. Decent dough and some char.

Great tasting pie. Sauce was good but was missing a little zip to be one of the greats. Also needs a little more crisp to the crust. Still a solid go to in JC

I love this place! Our company orders from here frequently. My first time actually coming to the actual shop and it’s amazing inside; highly recommend!!

Lotta flop lotta chew. Great flavor. Wish it were a bit crunchier.

This was all that was left of our 2 pies. This is the place to go in downtown Jersey city