John's Pizzeria of Times Square

Great pizza! John’s never disappoints. The cook was great, pizza was crispy. Not overly cheesy, not sloppy like the one Dave reviewed. Crust is perfect, under carriage slightly charred in spots. Very good sauce. One of the best I’ve ever had. Try the garlic rolls… like a garlic not but 10x better. They have mozzarella in the middle and pizza sauce for dipping.

Incredible crust. 10/10. A medium miss on the toppings. Personal preference obviously but I would've had a bit less cheese and a bit more sauce. It also was improved by adding a little bit of salt on top.

We stopped in for dinner last week and my wife isn’t a big NY pizza person so we grabbed a Calzone and it was absolutely amazing. She liked it so much we came back the next day for lunch and grabbed a pizza for lunch and it was just as good as the Calzone.

Super fresh. Perfect crust. No coke products. Must order full pie (no slices). Delicious.

Monster Score from the Kid

Sweet sauce , excellent pizza to start off New York, recommend from the best bar tender in NYC

Great dough, sauce (on top only?) and cheese…airy, chewy, slight crunch dough….poppin sauce (not too chunky) and melted, salty, creamy, cheese….ate whole pie with so, easily.

Was nervous it would be a little toursity but really solid pizza and very reasonable price.

Great sauce. Crust is good. Cheese is excellent and evenly spread. Coal fired oven traditional style. Comes in 14” or 16”.

Its ok -preety good for john i was expecting more lots of flop cheese was very chewy so yeah crust was good sayce was good

Zero flop. Crisp was perfect

Extreme wolf 🐺 possible New York tourist trap 🪤 Eye test - weak Execution - ok Ratio - fair. Not enough sauce Sauce - fresh but void of spice. Quality, and works with everything else as a whole Cheese - pretty generic blend. Works as a whole but not outstanding by itself Dough - exceptional taste and bake. Very good Travel worthy - absolutely not. You can do way better in NY. Bernstein said, “To achieve great things, two things are needed: a plan, and not quite enough time.

good crunch to the crust. Little to no flop. Gave the plain cheese an 8.2.

Pizza was great. Traditional felt like too much crust not enough cheese but the crust was excellent.

This is their traditional Gluten Free pie…absolutely amazing!!

Excellent

Margarita pizza great sauce cheese just tasted off for some reason

Solid, not amazing