John's Pizzeria of Times Square

Solid

My daughter and I thought this place was solid. Almost put down an entire large pie.

Pretty good! Good flop and sauce to cheese ratio, maybe not as good as Dave's other 8s but I'd say a solid contender

Creamy taste, firm undercarriage, crust is nicely toasted. We got VERY lucky and sat right away but usually be ready for a looong wait

Quite delicious

Great crust Cheese is tasty Sauce is spot on No flop Wood fired cooked crispy Overall good pie

Solid, could be cooked little longer

Solid pie. Barely any flop, crust was crunchy, sauce tasty, and cheese was very good and noticeable. Pleasantly surprised given the fact this place is right next to Times Square and all the tourists.

The ratings speak for themselves

Sweet sauce

This pizza was surprisingly good. At first glance, you wouldn’t expect much, but the thin crust was well-cooked with no flop—the way this pizzaiola likes it. Flavor was spot-on, with cheese and sauce evenly balanced across the pie. A true winner in the heart of Times Square.

Fantastic pizza. Sauce is great. Environment was also nice. Solid.

Solid dough and crisp. Sauce is great but in dollops. Cheese lacks flavor.

Great sauce and crust