John's Pizzeria of Times Square

Nice service! Loved the crust! Sidenote: Caesar salad was good too

Really solid pie. Did not have the wow factor I was hoping for. Great cook on it, but sauce was a little heavy on this bad boy.

Good slice

Crispy, chewy, some char. Sauce immediately reminded me of tomato soup. Very good overall.

Unbelievable pizza

As close to perfect as pizza can get

The crust was amazing. Great New York pizza

Great pizza for New York. Wouldn’t go out of my way for it.

Really good pizza. Crispy, light enough that you could eat a lot of slices, excellent sauce.

Big New York flop. Greasy. Undercarriage and crust doesn’t have a *great* crunch but decent. Good flavor that’s a bit unique.

That crust was crisp, and sauce was on point, the first 2 slices had zero flop. Char was phenomenal

UNREAL

Great flavor and sauce. Could have been more well done! Still amazing

More time in oven would have bumped this score a lot

Unbelievable

Great pizza every time.

Oddly not as good as John’s of Bleexker even know they have the same recipe. Could have used another minute in the oven

Love the sauce

Paper thin with a unique saltine flavory dough which complements the sauce and cheese well. Unique twist in the cheese with a parm reggiano taste. Could have been a little more well done. Bit floppy. Could use more evenly distributed sauce too. Excellent za though