Johns Wildwood Pizzeria

Crispy crust, good flavor, little bit of flop. Solid pizza in this area. Was voted Best Pizza in Erie 2024

I’ve had a lot of pizza from John’s in Edinboro but the Erie location is good too. Something about it feels only slightly not as good as the other location. Maybe because the store is so clean that it has an effect on the quality of the food. Or maybe it’s just my mind trying to accept the same pizza from a different location when there really is no difference at all. I dunno. Whatever the case, it’s still a well-balanced pizza that easily dominates over most of the other spots in town. It’s damn good.

Excellent sauce great crust could use just a little more cheese. Awesome place inside definitely worth the trip!

Very good thin crust. Extra points for being attached to a brewery. Pizza by the slice. Fresh mushrooms and plus.

Nice crust and chew. Consistent

Good Za

Got it well done. Goes great with the beer at Erie brewing company

This saucy thin crusted beauty rates up there with one of the better Pizza shops in Erie... This pizza has a beautiful under carriage with a good crisp, and a substantial flop... Tastes great after that long filthy night of partying it up at Penn State Behrend...

Nice tasting ingredients, nice doneness, flavorful crust.

If you’re looking for a great pizza place close to campus, this should be your choice. After a bite you can taste a little spice mixed with a sweet sauce. Proves for a great after taste. Quick turnaround times for orders, only 25-30 minutes on a good day. Great place to go!

This pizza graduated from the Lebron James school of flopping. Some serious Erie, PA flop. Crust was pretty solid. Sauce and cheese were good. This pizza was the girl you pick up at a bar after you’re drunk but its not last call. Certainly a good pizza , you aren’t ashamed you brought it home but you won’t brag to your buddies about it either.

Good sauce and dough

Sauce has some really good flavor. Well seasoned and a nice crisp to it as well. Overall delicious, would definitely recommend

Very good crisp, good flavor.

Bar food

Decent crunch, good flavor. Perfect for a football game.

Ordered well done for a better bite. Quality za.

Pepperoni/hot pep. Make sure you distinguish hot peps from banana bs. Crusts a bit doughy but I like it. 7.3 for Erie pizza which is King in the North IMO

Above average, top 3 pies in Erie. Great options for toppings. This is a white with red peppers, artichoke hearts and feta 🤙🏻

Little doughy, no crunch but over good.