Josie's Pizzeria Catering & Restaurant

7.2…. Solid pizza. Can’t go wrong.

This is nice. Plain slice has a good sauce, enjoyable crust and a solid undercarriage. Maybe I’m hungrier than usual, maybe I’ve had too much terrible pizza recently. But this slice certainly is a solid one.

I read the other reviews A little greasy but cheese taste good (pretty good mozzarella) Sauce is fine (not too sweet) Solid if you’re in the area

Round pie which score is based on was really solid, nice crisp, no flop and tasty ingredients. Sicilian was solid I’d give that an 8

Very flavorful cheese, I personally prefer a crispier crust and it was a bit floppy for my liking. A little oily but nothing too crazy, very good pizza

Sauce has a good taste. Crust is cooked well, not floppy. Could have used a little more cheese in my opinion. Good taste all around.

Extremely greasy cheese that is holding back the pizza. Sauce is sweeter than most and the crust doesn’t have much flavor. Good slice if your in the area

Good, relatively thin crust, crispy slices. Good sauce: cheese ratio. Reminded me of Pizza Town except... not quite as tasty, and the people were nicer. Not true Jersey pizzeria types.

Ate here a little less then a year ago can't believe Dave reviewed this place?!?! This is a below average pie with very sweet sauce and I can't stand sweet sauce. Would not recommend.

No crisp has a sweet sauce good amount of cheese

I didn’t taste the sweetness like Dave said... but I’m no expert. Was a great solid pie I could eat everyday.

Looked pretty standard pizza however the flavor of sauce is sneaky good and very light airy crust. Quite addicting pizza

It was ok. Sauce was sweet and it wasn’t crispy.... but it wasn’t bad. The owner is a doll.

You can’t really tell by looking at it, but this is surprisingly crispy. Not your traditional crisp with a well-done crunch...more of a deep fried zeppole crisp to the dough, which is really tasty, has great texture & consistency. The star of the pie is the deliciously sweet & flavorful sauce. It has a nice homemade by an Italian grandma quality. While the cheese is somewhat generic, it’s both smooth & rigid in areas, not particularly great. Overall, this is very good pizza, just missing out on the 8s cause it’s not really worth traveling for. But if you’re looking for a fastball right down the pipe, a solid neighborhood pie & Friday night takeout go-to, this joint hits the spot.

Nice slightly sweet pie! Vodka sauce is superb as well!

Very crispy, very sweet sauce.

Sauce is very bland. Cheese is sparse. If I didn’t get it well done, this score could have easily been somewhere in the 5.9-6.1 range. The well done gave it a bump.