Justino's Pizzeria

Mexican music, small booth to sit in

Big slice with good flavor!

Hands down some of the best NY pizza I’ve had. It’s a classic NY style pizza with a thin crust, but had very little grease and 100% passed the flop test. The sauce on the plain cheese was delicious and the white pizza was so flavorful (most white pizzas don’t have a ton of seasoning). It was so good I went twice in one day! 🍕🤌

Ordered the pie on Slice along with garlic bread and drinks. Had it delivered to Hyatt hotel around the corner on Wall St. Still hot when delivered. Very little flop, good flavor. Score might have been a little higher if the drinks brought would have been correct. Good pie for our first ever in NYC.

Margarita 8.0 plain 7.0

Pretty good, just not memorable. One of the better slice joints in fidi but can’t keep up with NoLita or Brooklyn

On plain, typical NY slice

Don’t love it, don’t hate it

Sauce was great. Crust was amazing, crunchy and doughy, but the cheese was a little bland

Really strong slice. Light and crispy. Little bit of grease but not too bad. Good crunch