This slice was EXCELLENT! Perfect balance of flavors among the sauce, caramelized cheese, and crisp crust. Order slices at the counter vs taking a pie home- the crust becomes soggier vs the great crisp out of the oven.
rushfan-duhpizzareviewdude2/14/21, 9:28 p.m.
Love tomato pie and hate this. All three components stink. Totally non-descript. If you are from Philly run, this is not for you.
8 views•0 likes
pinedevil771/10/21, 4:13 p.m.
Been coming here for years, never disappoints -original taste that you can’t find anywhere else , sauce is always good , if you like tomato pie this is one of the best, Dave needs to come here and review this pie!
sevvy12/20/20, 2:36 p.m.
The most amazing Sicilian style tomato pie you’ll have. Crust has just the right amount of crisp and not as thick as Sicilian but not thin crust. And the sauce bursting with flavor!
sleazyc12/6/20, 3:09 p.m.
Not normally big on the saucy, tomato pie type pizzas but exceptions must be made.
meron.rubinowitsch11/6/20, 6:18 p.m.
Dough was cooked more than Pete’s but sauce was much less impressive. Give the nod to Pete’s today.
mountlaurellikestheeagles11/5/20, 6:42 p.m.
Tangy very tasty square pie. Great taste little cheese but its a tomato pie. Worth the trip
justin.turner10/9/20, 9:58 p.m.
Similar to Pete’s (as they are in the same farmer’s market development). Lots of sauce with cheese underneath. Sauce is not as distinct, but definitely has more of a crisp.
daveturner10/9/20, 9:37 p.m.
In the same farmers market as Pete’s. Same exact style pizza crust was crispier with Kate and Als (Philly or ‘Trenton’ Tomato Pie). Tangy tomato sauce. Best farmers market pizza I ever had... (that being these 2 places were the only time I ever had pizza at a farmer market ;)
aaronpinto7/3/20, 1:20 a.m.
I’m new to the One Bite scene but I’m already very much a student of it—my whole life I’ve been a pizza purist (team plain all day, baby) and a very harsh critic. And I’m still going 9.8 on Kate and Al’s. That’s right—9.8. Wanted to go 9.9 but I’ll leave a PINCH of headroom for another pizza to top it. Granted, I just don’t see that happening. It’s like, sure there MAY be another Beatles, but let’s not kid ourselves. It’s beyond Sicilian or other square pies—it’s truly the gold standard of Sauce (capital S), crust, and cheese. Death row food. That’s a review.
anthonyzingerman3/8/20, 1:03 a.m.
My favorite square slice I think! Between here & Brooklyn Square in Jackson, NJ
mickla272/8/20, 3:17 p.m.
All flop, pizza soup. The sauce kinda tasted like spaghetti-os, but the cheese was great. Can’t beat a $2.50 slice
chris.shyne2/2/20, 3:43 p.m.
Surprsingly good Trenton style tomato pie. No flop. Crispy and delicious crust. Tangy tomato sauce. In the Columbus Flea market inside building at the end of the L
190 views•3 likes
headshoes12/8/19, 9:11 p.m.
Remember.. this a tomato pie... Super Crispy, Saucey, and a little bit of cheese.. been coming here for years.. Some tips: To go pies — Order them half baked... then throw the slices in the oven when you get home... tastes super fresh! No reheated slices at counter... everything is fresh.. ready to go, except you may have to wait 10 min for a slice
jason.peak10/18/19, 10:19 p.m.
Rated this pizza higher than normal due to the extremely low scores that some people put on here… By far and away one of the best tomato pies it’s actually a Hungarian recipe. Order ahead. True score is probably a 8.1-8.2.
subdiver9/14/19, 4:23 p.m.
In the Columbus Farmers Market, the best farmers market pizza I had so far, will try Pete’s pizza in a minute. Good and plenty of sauce, crunchy greasy bottom.
orangestreak8/18/19, 4:36 a.m.
I love this pizza. Lots of tomato flavor, a little cheese and thick crust. Perfect "Grandma" style slices.
patrick.bruce18/17/19, 7:04 p.m.
Mediocre attempt at a square pie stiff crust felt like I bit into a hidden valley crunch bar just ok cheese not enough sauce
pizzaworld7/26/19, 7:31 p.m.
Kate and Al’s is one of my favorite pizza places to go they are so good. The pizza is saucy and the crust is so good we ordered a regular pie and this one has extra cheese. Ever time we come here the pizza always come out great but stick to the regular. So I give this pizza a 8.9:)
mcnulty7/11/19, 5:14 p.m.
Nice tangy sauce. Very fresh. Wish the crust was done a little bit more.