It's good, definitely worth trying if you're in the area, and the place is very cool. Other food was good as well. Does it live up to "best pizza in NJ" per some magazine review? No. It's good though. Probably one of the best in the Mahwah/Ramsey area.
catchawave125/14/23, 12:53 a.m.
If you like a Bar Pie or “Bar Stool Style” pizza, you will love this pie. This is a cracker thin, 14” pie with some decent char. There’s no reason to ask for well done or crispy, it will come that way automatically. Good cheese to sauce ratio. Sauce is good but not great, except the Vodka Pie which was delicious and IMO more of an Angry or Slightly Spicy Vodka. I have to admit that Thin Crust Bar Pie isn’t my favorite style but this is a great pie that is always consistent and will never disappoint. Definitely worth a drive for, it ranks up there with The Columbia Inn in Montville and a little behind Angeloni’s in Caldwell.
mike.remick4/23/23, 5:30 p.m.
First time here, wow. Not only was the waiter good and in on the app, the pizza was great. There was plenty of cheese and it had a nice sharp taste. Very good. The crust was so thin, zero flop and was crisp. I am a big sauce guy, wish there was more sauce, but I get why. We’re talking paper thin here. Great place great atmosphere, will be back.
kbaytheboss4/1/23, 8:31 p.m.
Absolutely fantastic!!!!! I’m not a NY pizza guy. This was the best pizza I’ve ever had in NY. The place itself is 9.5 & the people are a 10! I’m not Portnoy but I know pizza and restaurants and this place is top of the line great!!!
mcrobrez13/4/23, 5:16 a.m.
Got Bubbles? Bar pizza strikes again at this location. Super thin slices, like eating pizza on a cracker. Not a huge fan as the crust just disintegrates as soon as you apply any pressure. The sauce had a little tang to the taste, otherwise wasn’t to bad. If your ok the area and haven’t tried bar pizza, this is a good introduction. Enjoy!!!
grubber801/20/23, 5:22 p.m.
Awesome bar pie! Sauce has a lot of flavoring and the crust is a nice crisp.
rob.rybicki1/7/23, 9:46 p.m.
Solid thin crust bar pie, would be happy to eat any time. Very straightforward in flavor, found the sauce fell a little flat for me. Great Jersey pub/tavern atmosphere.
cpfc9/12/22, 12:52 a.m.
A north jersey classic doesn’t disappoint. Phenomenal crisp, even cheese and sauce game. Tough to beat in the bar pie game
angus.mackenzie8/29/22, 12:44 a.m.
This pizza was sooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo goooooooooooood it killlllleeeeedddddd meeeeeee
jt428/21/22, 11:27 p.m.
Great tasting, thin crusted bar pizza. Sauce is tasty and cheese is good too! A definite place to hit up if you’re close by.
ben.ryan38/13/22, 5:07 p.m.
Amazing pizza just makes you want to run into the road naked and scream I love cheese pizza pizza🤌🤌
ben_krauss7/25/22, 12:11 a.m.
My dad’s friend hyped this place up, and my family and I were seriously disappointed. The pizza was soggy, and lacked any real flavor. The garlic we ordered was placed on very haphazardly, and wasn’t cooked in to the pizza. I fail to see why this place gets any business. We are the pizza in a park a mile away because of a dog, so the pizza should have been pretty fresh.
aidan.veres7/17/22, 7:44 p.m.
Pretty great. Perfect thin crust with no flop and great char. Good sauce / cheese ratio with the sweet flavor of the cheese being the best part.
cooperlinc4/16/22, 12:59 a.m.
Amazing plain 8.3.....Sausage, mushroom, and onion 7.3-A little too much on a very thin pizza
tommyg6882/5/22, 7:13 p.m.
Been looking forward to trying for some time. Frankly the Best Bar pie I ever tasted. Thin, crispy, great sauce to cheese ratio, zero flop. Amazing pizza. I wished it was my local place I could eat this all the time.
finkey.cold.medina1/26/22, 12:05 a.m.
Thinny thin. Fra Diovolo for some more zing. Kinda greasy tbh, but still a solid pie.