About Kinchley's Tavern
688 Yelp Reviews
brian.creeley2/14/21, 4:08 p.m.
Crust was amazing and crisp...slices were thin and well done for bar pizza.
roda11471/21/21, 11:45 a.m.
Kinda disappointed waited over an hour for a table. Pizza was boring and undercooked. I'm sure that's not how it always is so I'm raising the score a little (from 6.3 to 6.9) I got the idea of how it will be well done and can easily say this is on the lower side of bar pies and won't be any higher then a 7.3 Meatball parm was amazing tho would actually go back for that if in the area
mh423981/20/21, 7:44 p.m.
Haven’t been in ages but wow this pie Fs. Great crisp and the crust sauce and cheese gel together well, other bar pies they sorta separate and crust gets exposed lacking flavor. If getting takeout you gotta eat it fast
jumbahjr1/17/21, 7:03 p.m.
In the battle of bar pies, kinchleys is my go to. Right sauce to cheese ratio, good crisp. Likely low 8s if I was eating there, but for takeout 7.8....
t.woo1/4/21, 8:16 p.m.
I think they started making it crispier after Dave’s review cause mine was perfect, great crisp/sauce people
jb1234512/18/20, 6:42 p.m.
Dave went a little low on this slice; the pizza is very flavorful, it’s a great bar slice, and the crust is the best part. This is just a textbook NJ bar slice, and definitely a place worth coming back to.
todd.merson112/16/20, 6:19 a.m.
It was amazing I couldn’t stop eating it. I had the crunch that Dave missed. Would definitely recommend.
portnoy_dont_know_shit11/2/20, 7:49 p.m.
Yes it’s a bar pie, technically. But, it packs huge flavor. Perfectly thin and crispy crust. Sweet sauce with a light touch of oregano. Well covered in cheese that packs just the right amount of grease. Not the best for takeout, unless you’re only traveling about 5 minutes or less, otherwise the dynamic of the pizza changes drastically since it’s such a thin pie. Under rate, because as always, Portnoy don’t know shit about pizza.
nick.mattingly210/4/20, 7:16 p.m.
Great bar pie, pretty crispy and crunchy how a bar pie should be🤘🏼
eliyahu.kheel6/9/20, 5:29 p.m.
It was decent. Definitely not crispy enough. And I really didn't like the sauce. But it wasn't too bad overall.